Roger Cole
Member
Why don't they call 4x5 the ideal format? It doesn't require any cropping. Who came up with this term? Sounds like bollocks to me.
Someone who first marketed a 6x7 or 6x4.25 camera came up with it, I think.
It is bollocks, I agree. Nothing wrong with those sizes, don't get my wrong, but there's nothing magical about that aspect ratio either. I've been shooting a lot of square photos lately since getting a 6x6 camera, but if one will work better cropped, I'll crop it to 6.45, 6x3.9876509672 or whatever works best for the composition. Same for my 4x5 negs and 35mm.
The only reason I have a 6x7 roll film back for my 4x5 was that I found one used at the right price and didn't find a 6x9. (Nor am I looking for one now since I also got a 6x7 carrier.)