| Bellows (mm) | Δ ext (mm) | RF indicates | Actual focus | Linear error | % error |
| 158 | 0 | ∞ | ∞ | 0 | 0% |
| 165 | 7 | 14.3 m | 18.6 m | –4.3 m | –23% |
| 172 | 14 | 7.7 m | 8.3 m | –0.6 m | –7% |
| 180 | 22 | 4.8 m | 5.0 m | –0.2 m | –4% |
| 190 | 32 | 3.6 m | 3.6 m | ≈ 0 m | ≈ 0% |
| 200 | 42 | 2.7 m | 2.6 m | +0.1 m | +4% |
| 228 | 70 | 1.8 m | 1.65 m | +0.15 m | +9% |
If it doesn't work you can always say you hate those filter cases anyway. When you sand that use wet and dry 1000 grit and use it wet. It will take longer but it will be much smother.
you are also more than welcome to send me the scan, and i’ll trace it in fusion 360, so that you have a 2D vector (.dxf)
This is what AI calculates will happen when I use it with the 180mm cam after giving it all my data. It's interesting that it would apparently give me two usable rangefinder distances (if it's real). I'll test it.
Tele-Arton 270 mm on 180 mm Horseman 970 cam
Infinity stop set to 158 mm
Bellows (mm) Δ ext (mm) RF indicates Actual focus Linear error % error 158 0 ∞ ∞ 0 0% 165 7 14.3 m 18.6 m –4.3 m –23% 172 14 7.7 m 8.3 m –0.6 m –7% 180 22 4.8 m 5.0 m –0.2 m –4% 190 32 3.6 m 3.6 m ≈ 0 m ≈ 0% 200 42 2.7 m 2.6 m +0.1 m +4% 228 70 1.8 m 1.65 m +0.15 m +9%
I wasn't looking at this earlier, because I don't know much about rf cams or the Horseman. However, I am pretty sure that some columns of numbers for focus distance that the AI has given you are incorrect. I don't know if that's due to, e.g., how you set the calculation up, or the problem is too unusual for the AI to parse it correctly, or it interpolates in some incorrect way.
If you set the infinity stop correctly for the lens infinity focus, and extend past infinity by some amount "e" (Delta in your table), and f=focal length, then d_image = f+e, and the subject distance from lens is given by:
1/(d_subject) = 1/f - 1/(f + e)
This is true whether the lens is a telephoto design or not. So for example, looking at the boldface line in your table: for an extension past infinity of 32mm, and f=270mm, it should be focused at 1/d_subject = 1/270 - 1/302, so d_subject = 2.6 meters. This is lens to subject distance, not film to subject, which is 2.9 meters. Either way, not the AI's 3.6 meters. This formula at bellows draw 228mm gives film-subject 1.55m, fairly close to your measurement of focus 1.65m.
Suppose the rangefinder works by sensing the total bellows length, and we set it up using the 180mm cam for a 180mm lens of normal design that has 180mm of bellows draw at infinity. Then on the boldface line, you have 190mm of bellows draw. So the RF "thinks" that it has f=180mm and e=10mm. This gives 1/d_subject = 1/180 - 1/190, so lens-to-subject, d_subject = 3.4 meters. The rf scale might be calibrated to film-to-subject distance, which would be 3.6 meters. That does agree with the AI's number. However, under these assumptions, when you have the bellows at 158mm, that would be too little bellows for a 180mm lens, and the RF should read beyond infinity, not infinity. So I'm also suspicious of the AI's numbers in that column.
With the caveat that I don't know if the RF is exactly keyed off total bellows length. But I suspect it does something like that, I doubt it mechanically senses where the infinity stop is. This is why, in principle, one needs different cams for different lenses of focal length f, because they have different infinity stop locations.
BTW, my friend, who used to make custom cams for various lenses never was able to create a mathematical formula to calculate the curve. Instead he did it the old fashioned way - by hand.
I have a cams my friend made for a Xenar 240mm f/5.5 and one for a Rotelar 270mm f/f5.5 which have a very slight slope to the end versus one for a Schnieder Super Angulon 90mm where the slope stops about 1/3 of the way from infinity.
Hey @ivan35mm , I gave up on making a 150mm cam through sanding plastic. I don't think I can get it accurate enough and the material doesn't seem like it will hold its shape for long. I was trying to make a DXF file for sendcutsend.com in Inkscape for this image, to make with steel, but I don't know the program and I'm struggling. Would you be able to make the DXF for me if you have time? The dimensions of the image are 40mm x 18.29mm. The cam is 1mm thick if it matters. Thank you again for the help.
Assuming they work
If they don't work with a 150mm brand A, they may work with a 150mm brand B. You won't know until you try it. I'd be willing to buy one from you to try one.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?