Tri-X rodinal and skies ;-(

Lachlan Young · Oct 21, 2020

ericdan said:
I used to use Microphen to push Tri-X but unfortunately that now costs $38 dollars per liter in Japan. Yes, 38! I’ve brought it up a few times here and wrote ILFORD about it. Must be a mistake when ID11 and the rest of their developers are more or less in line with prices outside of Japan. That’s that.
HC-110 was made “illegal” in Japan back in 2015. Used it before I used Microphen.... sad story. Let’s hope xtol stays in Japan.

To the best of my understanding Fuji's Super Prodol developer effectively equates to Microphen and Microfine to Perceptol.

relistan · Oct 21, 2020

ericdan said:
You think a lower dilution of Rodinal would make a noticeable difference?

Naysayers will tell you no, but experience says yes. People have had decent results pushing in 1+100 stand. And there is a noticeable difference between a 20 minute dev in 1+100 and a stand development of an hour, with agitation first full minute and for 30 secs at 30 mins. Probably not worth debating with folks, but I recommend giving it a shot. Diafine is now expensive to play with but again my results have been very good in it. I think you already know that shooting 1600 means losing shadows, so objections that neither of these will get your more shadow details are beside the point.

EDIT: Here's a link to a Flickr search so you can see results people have gotten with 1+100 stand Tri-X at 1600 https://www.flickr.com/search/?text=rodinal 1+100 stand 1600 tri-x

Athiril · Oct 21, 2020

ericdan said:
Yes that’s right. I would like to keep using it at 1600. I like the contrast and shooting flexibility I get with it. Just didn’t like the grain.

Well, use Xtol. If it’s too fine, use dilute Xtol, if you don’t like how it looks add a solvent to Rodinal. Or add some Rodinal to dilute Xtol. Or use T-Max 400 @ 1600 in Rodinal

DREW WILEY · Oct 21, 2020

Tri-X and a nice autumn sky with a flock of ducks flying across it ... Just tell folks there were a bunch of duck hunters down below, and what appears in the scene is all the shotgun shot in the air. The only problem with that, is that with TriX in certain developers, it looks more like buckshot than birdshot, esp when gross underexposure is offset by gross overdevelopment, which is the case in this thread.

ericdan · Oct 21, 2020

Different tastes... You as an 8x10 shooter. Not surprised you like minimal grain photos. Would love to see some of your work.

DREW WILEY · Oct 22, 2020

The web is no place for that. Been there, done that, waste of time.

ericdan · Oct 23, 2020

DREW WILEY said:
The web is no place for that. Been there, done that, waste of time.

Feel ya!

Tri-X rodinal and skies ;-(

Lachlan Young

relistan

Athiril

DREW WILEY

ericdan

DREW WILEY

ericdan

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency