Again -- you are sampling that segment of the population who are too stupid or lazy to survive on their own.
Should I compare all 911 operators to the operator I connected with at 2am weekday to report a non-occupied car on fire...from a pay phone telling them the road and intersection? Thankfully there was no lives in danger. And I certainly have messed up emergency calls (phone and radio) in my days. Dislike them both (phones and radios), to be honest.
I like someone's "seeing to compose". It is just about right, except factor in the question: If I use the art of photography to learn how to see and I am successful, would I still photograph? Would I put the camera down as a tool no longer needed? Perhaps. I am certainly enjoying seeing lately without a camera. I am not 'seeing to compose', of course, but observing with more intent perhaps, using skills, knowledge, and an appreciation of the light gained through making photographs. Coupled with an appreciation of watersheds through years of working with land restoration and wilderness work, as well as backpacking, and all that fine stuff.
"Seeing" brings all one's skills, experiences, knowledge, and emotions together. The opening of one's eyes is only the beginning. An upside down backward image is thrown across the retinas and firing off sensors; and on its way to our consciousness, it goes through a lot of manipulations and changes. We see what we want to see, or conditioned to see. Eye witness testimony in courts is not as strong as it seems it should be.
YMMD