how to make fomapan 100 or 200 look 'like tri-x"?

[removed account4]

hi. i am using trays. old tupperware in fact you?

same here !
i also have old FR tanks i use sometimes if i am "semi/stand developing" ( only 4x5 ) but i don't use them often
they are a pain to load in the dark.

 

[removed account4]

But it will still be a VW. You know it is a VW. Everyone else knows it is a VW. It still will never be a Porche.

it was designed by a porsche designer and sold under a different name
for all intents and purposes a kharman ghia is a porsche whether it has the name plate or not.
chris77 isn't attempting to fool anyone into thinking he is using tri x
he likes the characteristics he likes and wants to save a few euros, why not
learn/figure out how to master how a film might be manipulated through exposure and development to let it do what you want?

sure some people don't like to do anything but shoot every film at box speed and process in d76 "as recommended" and they are happy with that
not everyone likes or wants to do that, and nothing is wasted by learning how to USE film, not just use it.

 

[Sirius Glass]

The vehicle ID will still identify it as a VW and nothing will ever change that, even fancy wheel covers or expensive wheels. Making a silk purse out of a sow's ear. Just get over it.

 

[removed account4]

The vehicle ID will still identify it as a VW and nothing will ever change that, even fancy wheel covers or expensive wheels. Making a silk purse out of a sow's ear. Just get over it.

i suppose appearences are important to a lot of people,
they are unimportant to others.
if under the hood it and behind the wheel
it drives like a car designed by the same person, that cost more
and is a target to be stolen it doesn't matter what name plate says it is - an unassuming car
that handles &c like a porsche.

the point is not to judge a book by its cover.

 

[MattKing]

The vehicle ID will still identify it as a VW and nothing will ever change that, even fancy wheel covers or expensive wheels. Making a silk purse out of a sow's ear. Just get over it.

Which would you prefer - a 2017 Mazda MX-5 or a 2017 Fiat 124 Spyder?
Or considering something older, how about a Toyota Matrix or Pontiac Vibe?
If I look in the right place in the engine compartment of my Fiat, it refers to Fiat and Maserati and Alfa Romeo and Lancia. Which should I choose?

 

[Sirius Glass]

Just because the Ford Focus and the Lincoln Continental come from the same factory does not make a Ford a Lincoln. We can even say that President Ford was not a President Lincoln.

 

[removed account4]

Just because the Ford Focus and the Lincoln Continental come from the same factory does not make a Ford a Lincoln.

.. ok, if you say so...
you seem to be fixated on
the phrase "turned into" and...
missed the point.

if someone took a ford focus and put a cushy im in a living room suspension, bullet proof windows and doors
and removed the rear seat and put a couch in it instead, then modified the engine to have more
"giddyup" and installed a lincoln grille ( ike the customized vw bug > rolls royce front ends )
certainly they will have turned it in a lincoln. and if they intstalled a hydrolic suspension and a scrape plate even better.

YMMV

 

[Sirius Glass]

The performance could be better but that does not change what is it. If I got a lot of money and built fancy palaces, I still would not become part of the Royal Family not matter how much I would want to.

 

[MattKing]

I'm curious Sirius, what you think about the X-Pan.
Or the Fuji version.

 

[removed account4]

The performance could be better but that does not change what is it. If I got a lot of money and built fancy palaces, I still would not become part of the Royal Family not matter how much I would want to.

i wasn't talking about performance being better, i was talking about customizing, transforming something into something else.
you obviously haven't seen the work of barron margo
http://www.baronmargo.com/about.html
with a little imagination anything can happen ..
and yes someone can use one film and allow it to have
similar characteristics of another ... as i suggeted before
the point is to USE the film not use it.

 

[Sirius Glass]

I'm curious Sirius, what you think about the X-Pan.
Or the Fuji version.

I have seriously thought about buying one with all three lenses and then again only with the 30mm lens. I just do not use my WideLux F7 very much and I just haven't fallen off the cliff yet.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First if all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[NB23]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

 

[trendland]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

There is a lot of marketing in "the play" you are right.
An people who are new - often are infected from marketing out of blogs.
But on the other hand it is not soo bad.
Manufacturers today may have good times if they notice : "There is a talk about"
And - as we all have learned - even bad news are good news.

with regards

PS : I sometimes had trouble with my smartphone - but yours seems to be more worst (multi multi posting).
So mine should be just ok.
(max. tribble posting)....

 

[DREW WILEY]

Classic grain Tri-X 320 is still made in sheets. The roll film 400 version is somewhat different, but certainly grainy enough to be annoying at times.

 

[sepiareverb]

Classic grain Tri-X 320 is still made in sheets. The roll film 400 version is somewhat different, but certainly grainy enough to be annoying at times.

Yes, but it doesn't come in his size.

 

[chris77]

I’m not sure why people talk so much about Tri-x as to how great it is.

First of all, Fomapan100 is absolutely marvelous! The best in my opinion. Tonal scale and color response is just great.

Today’s tri-x has NOTHING to do with the tri-x we are refering to when we talk about tri-x. Unfortunately, newbies are victims of marketing as far as tri-x goes: they love tri-x but they don’t know why, they couldn’t separate it from delta400.
Grain? Tri-x has grain now? Since 2007 there’s no grain in tri-x worth talking about, and yet loads of people talk about it, but what they actually do is parrot the internet discussions they read here and there.

Too much dismissive and blanket statements when film is in question. And please don’t get me started on “stand”, “semi-stand developments”, as well as “gentle agitations”.

so much unnecessary subtext.
please, instead of assuming truckloads of non existant information, take a walk.
this thread was not meant to offer a place for spam.

i am shooting tri x since 2014. i am aware that this new tri x has been reformulated before. i honestly dont care.
tri x - as i know it (120) - is a wonderful film.
the title of this thread indicated that i am looking for ideas/thoughts on how to achieve a ''similar look" with foma film .it was asked in order to gather inspiring ideas, nothing else.
thanks for respecting that.

ps. you should give minimal agitation a try. the edge effects enhance the beautiful grain pattern of tri x.

 

[chris77]

There is a lot of marketing in "the play" you are right.
An people who are new - often are infected from marketing out of blogs.
But on the other hand it is not soo bad.
Manufacturers today may have good times if they notice : "There is a talk about"
And - as we all have learned - even bad news are good news.

with regards

PS : I sometimes had trouble with my smartphone - but yours seems to be more worst (multi multi posting).
So mine should be just ok.
(max. tribble posting)....

trouble with tribbles... sigh