Would anyone be willing to help me diagnose what went wrong here?
This is HP5+ stand developed 54 mins in homebrew FX-2, rinsed twice with water, fixed in TF5 for 10 minutes, using a Fedco tank.
I've used all the chemistry to successfully process other films tonight so I'm at a loss. The negative is still in the rinse as I write this.
Any help is appreciated.
View attachment 82066
ps. the problem is the pink remaining on one side.
Looks like the film hasn't been fully immersed in the developer and fixer, in some tanks the spiral rises up the column and then isn't fully submerged. Paterson and Jobo use locking rings to ensure this doesn't happen, often these don't get used.
It looks like something like that has occurred, you need to check your tank.
Ian
It's sheet film, unlikely to be in a spiral.
RR
Looks like the film hasn't been fully immersed in the developer and fixer, in some tanks the spiral rises up the column and then isn't fully submerged. Paterson and Jobo use locking rings to ensure this doesn't happen, often these don't get used.
It looks like something like that has occurred, you need to check your tank.
Ian
I think Ian has probably got it right then. That slotted frame would indeed have the same effect as a spiral, but is there any possibility of the frame slipping upwards in the tanks and then staying up as the tank is put down to wait for the next period of agitation? Did you have the Kodak film that came out perfectly in at the same time as the HP5 plus? If you did then I would consider whether the film came out of one of its slots and ended up partially shielded during the processing.
RR
Rod, thanks for the response.
There was zero agitation done. I set the tank down, poured in 500ml from one pitcher, 1,000ml from another pitcher and walked away for 54 minutes.
And as you can see in the photo, the spiral sits very near the top of the tank, so with the lid on there wouldn't have been enough space for it to slip upwards.
I didn't use any kodak film ... only HP5+ ... and the two negatives, which I processed last night and which came out fine, were stand processed using my other daylight tank with hangers.
On the spiral, once the film is slid into its slots, there is a lip, which holds it in place and it takes some moderate difficulty to remove the film intentionally, which makes me doubt it coming loose unintentionally.
Ah well! If it had happened to me I have to say I would have diagnosed some finger trouble on my part.
RR
Ten four. I will give it another go tonight.
I'm quite certain I will have earned the ability to shoot / process / print 4x5 by the time I have this all figured out!
EDIT: here in Nebraska, US, "Ten four" is a radio reply for "affirmative" or "understood." Not sure if that expression means anything in UK.
As in "roger" or "roger that"?
It's sheet film, unlikely to be in a spiral.
RR
My Jobo 2000 series tanks take 2 5x4 reels, perhaps spiral was the wrong word but that's what the 120 & 35mm versions are called. Paterson tanks take the MOd 54 which fits in place of the spiral reels.
So it's quite a common problem for these sheet holders to rise up a column and not drop back, I've seen it happen a few times when the locking collars aren't used.
Ian
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?