xya, what aperture was your vignetted example shot at? I ask because the typical w/a lens gains coverage on stopping down for two reasons. It gains illumination far off-axis because for most w/a lenses stopping down reduces mechanical vignetting. And it gains image quality far off-axis because stopping down reduced off-axis aberrations.
Further on this point, as I calculate it a 90 degree lens should be 1.1 stops down in the 6x12's corners. I could be mistaken, but y'r example shot seems to be darker than that in the corners.