$3,890,500!!!

Oranges

A
Oranges

  • 3
  • 0
  • 60
Charging Station

A
Charging Station

  • 0
  • 0
  • 54
Paintin' growth

D
Paintin' growth

  • 3
  • 0
  • 55
Spain

A
Spain

  • 5
  • 0
  • 59

Forum statistics

Threads
198,111
Messages
2,769,772
Members
99,563
Latest member
WalSto
Recent bookmarks
0

holmburgers

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2009
Messages
4,439
Location
Vienna, Austria
Format
Multi Format
Let me answer your question with another one, if this image was put on APUG Gallery by me as my work with an audience of almost fifty thousand photographers, how many of them would you think would be falling over themselves proclaiming what a great work of art it is ?

There's been a lot of great posts in the interim, but I just want to respond to this.

1st off, your question doesn't answer my question.

I don't know how I can answer such a hypothetical question, but if this picture were in the APUG gallery, yes, I do think it would catch my eye. Would I fall over myself? Well, let me answer that with a question... was I falling over myself about this work of art or just defending it?
 

benjiboy

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 18, 2005
Messages
11,953
Location
U.K.
Format
35mm
There's been a lot of great posts in the interim, but I just want to respond to this.

1st off, your question doesn't answer my question.

I don't know how I can answer such a hypothetical question, but if this picture were in the APUG gallery, yes, I do think it would catch my eye. Would I fall over myself? Well, let me answer that with a question... was I falling over myself about this work of art or just defending it?
I think we had just better agree to disagree because there is nothing that is going to persuade me that this photograph is art.
 
OP
OP
eclarke

eclarke

Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
1,950
Location
New Berlin,
Format
ULarge Format
There's been a lot of great posts in the interim, but I just want to respond to this.

1st off, your question doesn't answer my question.

I don't know how I can answer such a hypothetical question, but if this picture were in the APUG gallery, yes, I do think it would catch my eye. Would I fall over myself? Well, let me answer that with a question... was I falling over myself about this work of art or just defending it?


I said this earlier, in person this photograph probably has great presence that a crappy web image can't convey. Web images are NOT!!!! photographs..EC
 

Steve Smith

Member
Joined
May 3, 2006
Messages
9,109
Location
Ryde, Isle o
Format
Medium Format
Viola was supposed to be Voila!! The auto spell correct sometimes makes interesting decisions....

That's why it's best not to use it!


Steve.
 

Steve Smith

Member
Joined
May 3, 2006
Messages
9,109
Location
Ryde, Isle o
Format
Medium Format
I think we had just better agree to disagree because there is nothing that is going to persuade me that this photograph is art.

I think we have had this discussion before but just as there can be good music and bad music, there can also be good art and bad art.

Defining it as art doesn't imply that it is any good.

A piece of music can be poorly composed with horrible harmonies and played on out of tune instruments (sounds like one of my gigs!) but it's still music.

Likewise, a painting or photograph can have poor composition, terrible choice of colours and lighting, etc. but it's still art.


Steve.
 

Early Riser

Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2005
Messages
1,676
Location
USA
Format
Multi Format
I agree, that is an incredibly small box.

Thankfully we can all have different sizes of "boxes", some big enough to include context and the passage of time as a foundation for understanding and appreciating works of art.



A small box in your opinion.

If you think I'm critical of Sherman's work you should check out what Duane Michals has to say about it. The first "chapter" of his book "Foto Follies" is all about her.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

2F/2F

Member
Joined
Apr 29, 2008
Messages
8,031
Location
Los Angeles,
Format
Multi Format
It is no longer just a photograph at this point. It is just a medium by which a rich person can shuffle their money/value around. Do you think very many people spend that much money on something simply because they truly enjoy it that much, and feel that it brings them 4 million dollars worth of joy in and of itself? Some do. Most do not. This is just investing, which is what makes it ridiculous to me. If you are going to invest, try something more interesting and important than a piece of flat art. Invent something. Start a business that supplies a need, and creates jobs. Start a gallery or a photography school if you really like photography and want to spend a bunch of money on it. Contribute to society. Have some imagination. But I guess that is harder than just buying a picture to resell it later.
 
OP
OP
eclarke

eclarke

Member
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
1,950
Location
New Berlin,
Format
ULarge Format
I think we had just better agree to disagree because there is nothing that is going to persuade me that this photograph is art.

On the Christie's site there was no mention that any art was sold, somebody bought a photograph they like...EC
 

removed account4

Subscriber
Joined
Jun 21, 2003
Messages
29,833
Format
Hybrid
A small box in your opinion.

If you think I'm critical of Sherman's work you should check out what Duane Michals has to say about it. The first "chapter" of his book "Foto Follies" is all about her.


yeah, but brian -
he's in a small room, not a small box :wink:
 

warden

Subscriber
Joined
Jul 21, 2009
Messages
2,965
Location
Philadelphia
Format
Medium Format
A small box in your opinion.

If you think I'm critical of Sherman's work you should check out what Duane Michals has to say about it. The first "chapter" of his book "Foto Follies" is all about her.

Actually a "tiny" box, in your opinion. Said so yourself, right? I'm just agreeing with you, man. :smile:

The fact that Sherman's art (or any art for that matter) might require some knowledge, context, or participation from the viewer to fully appreciate it does not diminish it at all to me. If it diminishes it to you, that's cool, don't buy art like that.

I just read a summary and some reviews of the Duane Michals book. I'll pass, thanks anyway.
 

jordanstarr

Member
Joined
Apr 30, 2007
Messages
781
Location
Ontario
Format
Multi Format
I don't know if it's been said or not...I honestly didn't want to read all 10 pages... but I think any photograph that sells for this much is a good reflection on photography being collectible as "art" and us film/darkroom users should be happy as this raises the bar of what our art is worth. Obviously, this is a bit of a generalization with some assumptions in it, but a big tide raises all boats.
 

Eric Rose

Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2002
Messages
6,841
Location
T3A5V4
Format
Multi Format
I'm still working on my steaming dog shit project. Once I get it finished I will sell it through one of those high faluten auction houses. That is once I have paid off one of the MOMA boys to fawn over it and call it "art". Maybe I should give my fellow APUG'rs first crack at it. Just think you could buy an 11x14 for $150 and in a few weeks turn around and sell it for millions!
 

Joe O'Brien

Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2010
Messages
170
Format
Multi Format
I have to say I agree with Jordanstarr. The fact that a photograph created with analog processes sold for this much reaffirms my belief that all of us here on this forum are invested in a viable art form.

As for what is art, my PERSONAL view is art is whatever the viewer sees to be art. Some may say this is just sidestepping the question, but I haven't found anyone that I've ever agreed on every piece with.
 

ianstamatic

Member
Joined
Aug 26, 2010
Messages
20
Format
Multi Format
This is awesome for photography as art and awesome for Cindy. Congrats !
 

Steve Smith

Member
Joined
May 3, 2006
Messages
9,109
Location
Ryde, Isle o
Format
Medium Format
This is awesome for photography as art

I don't think it is. Whilst we as photographers might think it's great that a photograph would sell for this much, the general public will look upon this with disbelief and I think it does more harm than good.


Steve.
 

keithwms

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2006
Messages
6,220
Location
Charlottesvi
Format
Multi Format
What possible harm could it do, Steve? Are people going to quit looking at photographs? Throw away their cameras? Quit their subscription to a photo magazine....? Throw a hissy fit and curse their day job?

If we're concerned about the credibility of the craft then this helps rather than hurts. This shows that a relatively unknown analogue photograph generated a huge amount of interest.

The way I see it, there is no harm done whatsoever. I can think of a lot of other recent events that do negatively affect the credibility of photographers as a whole. But certainly not this.
 

Steve Smith

Member
Joined
May 3, 2006
Messages
9,109
Location
Ryde, Isle o
Format
Medium Format
What possible harm could it do, Steve? Are people going to quit looking at photographs?

No. They are going to start thinking about them in the same way they think about some of the nonesense which gets entered for the Turner Prize and other items of conceptual art which sell for great sums usually to people with more interest in investment than art.


Steve.
 

keithwms

Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2006
Messages
6,220
Location
Charlottesvi
Format
Multi Format
Okay but how has that hurt art as a whole? Perhaps it has attracted some kinds of impostors who mimic that and try to earn a quick buck from it. Does that really turn anyone away from the more genuine craft? (assuming one really thinks this isn't genuine) I don't think so. It's not a zero sum game. People who like paint splatters probably wouldn't buy my stuff anyway....
 

M.A.Longmore

Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2009
Messages
2,024
Location
Drinking From A Fountain
Format
Multi Format
I don't know if it's been said or not...I honestly didn't want to read all 10 pages... but I think any photograph that sells for this much is a good reflection on photography being collectible as "art" and us film/darkroom users should be happy as this raises the bar of what our art is worth. Obviously, this is a bit of a generalization with some assumptions in it, but a big tide raises all boats.
.
It's a great time to be a photographer.
Hopefully, an APUG Member will reach that level, someday ...

Ron
.
 
Joined
Jan 21, 2003
Messages
15,708
Location
Switzerland
Format
Multi Format
.
It's a great time to be a photographer.
Hopefully, an APUG Member will reach that level, someday ...

Ron
.

As mentioned earlier, Ron, I'd love to sell one of my photos for half that. That's a 50% discount. :sideways:
 
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom