SFC
Member
I NEVER, NEVER, NEVER , NEVER crop. My neg holders are filed to the edges as evidence of the fact (To me, cropping, for the most part, seems dishonest, something that should only be done if the photographer is somehow physically restrained from framing the image exactly as he/she would prefer to do!).
A rather silly and dogmatic opinion that has nothing to do with the OP's question (just an opportunity to shove your aesthetics down everyone's throat). Perhaps it's just to show the world you own a Hasselblad? Just look at the work of some great photographers (like David Plowden) and you'll see that adhering to some predetermined aspect ration for every photo is artistically constraining and in the end, just macho. It's nothing worth bragging about. You might as well say "I NEVER EVER use a tripod" or "I never EVER use anything other than f2.8!"
I don't understand where the concept of "dishonest" enters into it. The final image is what you determine it. You're implying that the viewer is being cheated somehow.
A rather silly and dogmatic opinion that has nothing to do with the OP's question (just an opportunity to shove your aesthetics down everyone's throat). Perhaps it's just to show the world you own a Hasselblad? Just look at the work of some great photographers (like David Plowden) and you'll see that adhering to some predetermined aspect ration for every photo is artistically constraining and in the end, just macho. It's nothing worth bragging about. You might as well say "I NEVER EVER use a tripod" or "I never EVER use anything other than f2.8!"
I don't understand where the concept of "dishonest" enters into it. The final image is what you determine it. You're implying that the viewer is being cheated somehow.