Wikipedia said:Fine art photography is photography created in accordance with the vision of the artist as photographer. Fine art photography stands in contrast to representational photography, such as photojournalism, which provides a documentary visual account of specific subjects and events, literally re-presenting objective reality rather than the subjective intent of the photographer; and commercial photography, the primary focus of which is to advertise products or services.
this ought to be a fun thread !
chris:
. i'm guessing if you say your dog images are fine art photography you will be able to sell them & your services
for a little more than if you just call them dog pictures .. or if you price them lower, people will KNOW they are
getting something expensive for a deal ...
It's all in the eye of the beholder. While I certainly agree that the term is often misused and usually taken as a pretentious way of doing things (galleries are the worst offenders), there's a legitimate use of the word. It's no different in photography than in any other art medium. What makes a piece of pottery a work of art, while another piece is craft? I'd have to say that you just know, or you don't. It's not that big a deal. Perhaps that's as good a definition as any though. It's work that is at another level beyond craft.
Calling a landscape print fine art photography is akin to calling an inkjet print a Giclee print because it sounds so much more superior to the layman.
Terms are all contextual. One has to see a list of terms to understand the nuance of one vs. the other. I would submit that photographs fall into these general categories of purpose:
- Commercial: to serve the purposes of a business enterprise with product or service to offer
- Industrial: to serve the purposes of non-commercial illustrations of inanimate objects/processes
- Scientific: to convey academic elements of inanimate or animate things
- Illustrative: to portray a written concept via graphic example
- Journalistic: for the purposes of print media articles and stories
- Portraiture: to present a likeness of an individual (or small group) in a manner consistent with how you might see them in a chance encounter
- Fine Art: 'for the sake of Art' (and serving none of the preceding listed purposes)
My point is not whether these are right/wrong, or that this is a comprehensive list. I present it merely as a foil against which 'fine art photography' is validly distinguished from other forms of photography. Other comparative lists can exist, just as validly. Unless a context of a list is presented, it is merely a 'term'
Similary 'PC' can mean 'printed circuit', 'personal computer', 'process controller', 'politically correct'...until you have a CONTEXT to compare within, 'PC' is merely a 'term' with no definition.
...Calling a landscape print fine art photography is akin to calling an inkjet print a Giclee print because it sounds so much more superior to the layman.
-1,293,591
The point is that it was invented as a marketing term and the word describes what the nozzle of the printer does, spray ink, i.e. an inkjet print. The other alternatives described above are all marketing terms as well. It makes me think people are ashamed of calling their prints waht they are which is inkjet prints. Every Gicleee print ever made has been made on an inkjet printer of some kind. What's wrong with the term inkjet? Whats wrong with the term black and white silver gelatin landscape print . What makes it "Fine Art" compared to an equally good print not described as "Fine Art". Art like beauty is in the eye of the beholder. If you need to tell the beholder then your print is lacking in something.What's In a Name: The Story of Giclée
One thing that became quickly apparent to the early digital pioneers was the lack of a proper name to describe the prints they were making. By the close of the 1980s, IRIS printers were installed all over the world and spinning off full-color proofs in commercial printing plants and pre-press shops. These prints were used to check color and get client approvals before starting the main print run. They definitely were not meant to last or to be displayed on anyone's walls. Most people called them "IRIS prints," or "IRIS proofs," or, more simply, "IRISes."
However, this wasn't good enough for the new digital printmakers like Maryann Doe of Harvest Productions and Jack Duganne, who was the first printmaker (after David Coons) at Nash Editions. They wanted to draw a distinction between the beautiful prints they were laboring over and the utilitarian proofs the commercial printers were cranking out. Just like artist Robert Rauschenberg did when he came up with the term "combines" for his new assemblage art, they needed a new label, or, in marketing terms, a "brand identity." The makers of digital art needed a word of their own.
And, in 1991, they got it. Duganne had to come up with a print-medium description for a mailer announcing California artist Diane Bartz' upcoming show. He wanted to stay away from words like "computer" or "digital" because of the negative connotations the art world attached to the new medium. Taking a cue from the French word for inkjet (jet d'encre), Duganne opened his pocket Larousse and searched for a word that was generic enough to cover most inkjet technologies at the time and hopefully into the future. He focused on the nozzle, which most printers used. In French, that was le gicleur. What inkjet nozzles do is spray ink, so looking up French verbs for "to spray," he found gicler, which literally means "to squirt, spurt, or spray." The feminine noun version of the verb is (la) giclée, (pronounced "zhee-clay") or "that which is sprayed or squirted." An industry moniker was born.
However, the controversy started immediately. Graham Nash and Mac Holbert had come up with "digigraph," which was close to "serigraph" and "photograph." The photographers liked that. But, the artists and printmakers doing reproductions had adopted "giclée," and the term soon became a synonym for "an art print made on an IRIS inkjet printer."
Today, "giclée" has become established with traditional media artists, and some photographers. But many photographers and other digital artists have not accepted it, using, instead, labels such as "original digital prints," "inkjet prints," "pigment prints," or "(substitute the name of your print process) prints."
For many artists, the debate over "giclée" continues. Some object to its suggestive, French slang meaning ("spurt"). Others believe it is still too closely linked to the IRIS printer or to the reproduction market. And some feel that it is just too pretentious. But, for many, the term "giclée" has become part of the printmaking landscape; a generic word, like Kleenex, that has evolved into a broader term that describes any high-quality, digitally produced, fine-art print.
One problem, of course, is that when a term becomes too broad, it loses its ability to describe a specific thing. At that point, it stops being a good marketing label and make no mistake about it, "giclée" is a marketing term. When everything is a giclée, the art world gets confused, and the process starts all over again with people coming up with new labels.
This is exactly what happened when a new group formed in 2001--the Giclée Printers Association (GPA)--and came up with its own standards and its own term: "Tru Giclée." The GPA is concerned with reproduction printing only, and its printmaker members must meet nine standards or principles in order for them (and their customers) to display the Tru Giclée logo.
In 2003, recognizing that only a small number of printmakers could meet the requirements of Tru Giclée, the GPA instituted a lower-threshold standard, "Tru Décor," which applies to the much larger decor-art market.
Others have also jumped on the giclée bandwagon with such variations as Platinum Giclée (Jonathan Penney's term for his black-and-white printmaking process), Canvas Photo Giclée (a California photo printmaking shop), and Heritage Giclée (Staples Fine Art's trademarked term for their brand of giclée printmaking).
giclée (zhee-clay) n. 1. a type of digital fine-art print. 2. Most often associated with reproductions; a giclée is a multiple print or exact copy of an original work of art that was created by conventional means (painting, drawing, etc.) and then reproduced digitally, typically via inkjet printing. First use in this context by Jack Duganne in 1991, Los Angeles, California.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?