I've had mostly good experiences with fomapan 200 in medium format, and I like the pictures I've gotten. I haven't seen the defects described, I don't think. But I can't speak for for their general QC, and I haven't shot so much that it couldn't be luck.
I think it's great in 35mm and sheet film format, but the QA is suspect in 120 roll film format. Some say this is solved, but I've gotten so used to people saying this and then the same problems popping up again that I've become numb to it. But again: great stuff in 35mm and sheet film!
It would be nice if our friends at Foma would let us know whether or not the "flaking emulsion" problem has been resolved or not. I would place an order today if I knew for sure, but as it is now I'll wait for a while.