I've never had a Pyrocat failure with the HDC, MC or HD version, but I only mix in glycol. I have had the HD version in glycol last 6+ years. After 3 of those years I mixed a new batch thinking the old batch could go anytime. I then switched to the new batch, but would test the old batch periodically and it was still good at +6 years when I finally dumped it. Damn good stuff! Yes, it's different than PMK or another pyro I use, WD2H+, but I like it much better overalll. Just me of course and you might have a different idea, which is fine with me.