Should the Monthly Shooting Assignment Accept Digital Photos?

[koraks]

I'd like to offer that if 25% (9 votes) are for digital-inclusion, this would be on the skimpy side to get a whole new MSA off the ground, but it carries the potential to enrich the present one.

 

[Don_ih]

I'd like to offer that if 25% (9 votes) are for digital-inclusion, this would be on the skimpy side to get a whole new MSA off the ground, but it carries the potential to enrich the present one.

I agree, although I don't know how many digital-only people saw this poll.

 

[koraks]

Yes, that's true. It's difficult to control for certain methodological artefacts.

 

[George Mann]

I voted yes, but agree that they should be kept seperate.

 

[Don_ih]

It looks like everyone who would vote has voted, and the results are roughly 2:1 against. But with 10 people voting that digital should be accepted, maybe there would be enough interest for a digital MSA.

 

[guangong]

There could be one for film and one for digital.

You know very well that simple solutions are not preferred on these forums!

 

[Kino]

It looks like everyone who would vote has voted, and the results are roughly 2:1 against. But with 10 people voting that digital should be accepted, maybe there would be enough interest for a digital MSA.

OK, is there a formal mechanism for inaugurating just such a beast by interested parties?

 

[Andrew O'Neill]

Since digital is a part of Photrio, there should be a digital MSA. So, just start one in the appropriate forum.

 

[Rolleiflexible]

It looks like everyone who would vote has voted, and the results are roughly 2:1 against. But with 10 people voting that digital should be accepted, maybe there would be enough interest for a digital MSA.

I voted yes but I would not participate in a digital MSA.

OK, is there a formal mechanism for inaugurating just such a beast by interested parties?

Post a new thread and see who replies.

 

[Anon Ymous]

I voted yes but I would not participate in a digital MSA.

I voted no, but I would participate in a digital MSA.

If anything, it would certainly be easier to meet deadlines. I had few photos that I shot for the previous MSA, but still haven't completed the roll, so they're undeveloped.

 

[Andrew O'Neill]

I voted yes but I would not participate in a digital MSA.



Post a new thread and see who replies.

As long as the thread is in the appropriate forum

 

[MattKing]

As long as the thread is in the appropriate forum

As the Member Organized Functions forum is a Mixed Workflow forum, it can happily co-exist side by side with the current MSA.
I'd be happy to help assist anyone who wants to organize it.
It should be reasonably easy to tweak the names, to avoid future confusion.

 

[George Mann]

I'd be happy to help assist anyone who wants to organize it.

What does one need to do to qualify?

 

[Don_ih]

Anyone can start a thread. So anyone can start a digital MSA. I probably would not take part, since I take almost no digital photos, so it would make little sense for me to start it.

 

[MattKing]

Anyone can start a thread. So anyone can start a digital MSA. I probably would not take part, since I take almost no digital photos, so it would make little sense for me to start it.

If the new venture garners enough interest, you can reach out to Sean to request your own sub-sub-forum, like the one this thread is in, or the others shown here in the Member Organized Functions area: