Good Afternoon, Dave,
I sympathize! The press I got free had a platen which also needed cleaning. The stuff which looks like varnish is probably residue from Seal MT5 mounting tissue. If you've found something which works well as a cleaner, congratulations. I used isopropyl alcohol, steel wool, and a lot of elbow grease. It did the job, but it took forever. This topic has been addressed before on APUG; a search should give you some additional information. One thing I think someone suggested is oven cleaner; I don't know how well it works, but it makes sense. Seal also makes a special platen cleaner. The last time I checked, Calumet had it at a price of around $30 for a small (8 oz. ??) bottle; I don't know what's in it or how well it works. Even if you use mat board over your prints, I'd still recommend that the platen be as clean and smooth as possible: you may someday want to use the press as a laminator.
Konical