• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

Rodinal failure

PenStocks

A
PenStocks

  • 0
  • 0
  • 9
Landed Here

H
Landed Here

  • 3
  • 2
  • 38

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
201,832
Messages
2,830,842
Members
100,977
Latest member
Gorrunyo
Recent bookmarks
0

Gerald C Koch

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Jul 12, 2010
Messages
8,131
Location
Southern USA
Format
Multi Format
Not necessary Richard, MSDS are slightly different.

Reading MSDSs can be difficult. Remember that manufacturers really don't want people to know what is in their proprietary formulas. They often resort to perfectly legal misdirection. For example hydroquinone can be called 4-hydroxyphenol or pap as either a substituted amine OR a substituted phenol. There are naming conventions in organic chemistry to prevent this but manufacturers seldom follow them. There are also various other subterfuges that can be used.
 
Last edited:

miha

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Feb 15, 2007
Messages
3,038
Location
Slovenia
Format
Multi Format
True, the key is Section 9.
 

Alan Johnson

Subscriber
Allowing Ads
Joined
Nov 16, 2004
Messages
3,375
I believe that when all the sulfite in Rodinal or variations is used up the p-aminophenolate left will oxidize.
There is a lot of sulfite in Rodinal and the p-aminophenolate does not hydrolyse, that is why it lasts so long.
I'm not convinced that any variation contains a compound that can inhibit oxidation of the bulk solution.
Therefore I favour the porosity of containers explanation.
 

Xmas

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
6,398
Location
UK
Format
35mm RF
I believe that when all the sulfite in Rodinal or variations is used up the p-aminophenolate left will oxidize.
There is a lot of sulfite in Rodinal and the p-aminophenolate does not hydrolyse, that is why it lasts so long.
I'm not convinced that any variation contains a compound that can inhibit oxidation of the bulk solution.
Therefore I favour the porosity of containers explanation.
Rodinal is merely a concentrated paraaminophenol developer.
In films hayday many people sold clones that lasted as well.
I've had a near empty bottle of Azol ok after a decade.
I've also forgotten to replace the cap on my current bottle!
Not had any failures with any of the clones.
You can get a lotta crystals cause the solution can be saturated.
I've mixed it from scratch. You need a full face visor.
Could be operator error?
 
OP
OP

jim appleyard

Subscriber
Allowing Ads
Joined
Nov 21, 2004
Messages
2,421
Location
glens falls, ny USA
Format
Multi Format
[QUOTE="Xmas, post: 1756456, member: 15409"

Could be operator error?[/QUOTE]

Doubtful. While I'm far from perfect, I'm a very careful darkroom user and I've been doing films in Rodinal for decades and have had no failure until recently. Real Rodinal from Agfa lasted forever and I once got ahold of a old glass bottle with the cork that was half-full. It was fine.

Now my APH09 lasts only a few months and it happens to all the films I dev in it and over the course of 3-4 bottles.

Blast Agfa anyway for going out of business!
 

JW PHOTO

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
May 15, 2006
Messages
1,148
Location
Lake, Michig
Format
Medium Format
[QUOTE="Xmas, post: 1756456, member: 15409"

Could be operator error?

Doubtful. While I'm far from perfect, I'm a very careful darkroom user and I've been doing films in Rodinal for decades and have had no failure until recently. Real Rodinal from Agfa lasted forever and I once got ahold of a old glass bottle with the cork that was half-full. It was fine.

Now my APH09 lasts only a few months and it happens to all the films I dev in it and over the course of 3-4 bottles.

Blast Agfa anyway for going out of business![/QUOTE]


Jim,
What is a person suppose to buy that is the closest to good old Agfa Rodinal?????
 

Xmas

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
6,398
Location
UK
Format
35mm RF
Doubtful. While I'm far from perfect, I'm a very careful darkroom user and I've been doing films in Rodinal for decades and have had no failure until recently. Real Rodinal from Agfa lasted forever and I once got ahold of a old glass bottle with the cork that was half-full. It was fine.

Now my APH09 lasts only a few months and it happens to all the films I dev in it and over the course of 3-4 bottles.

Blast Agfa anyway for going out of business!


Jim,
What is a person suppose to buy that is the closest to good old Agfa Rodinal?????[/QUOTE]
I'm the most carefree (careless) worker and I've not had any problems (yet).
You can scratch mix up a
published recipe or PA Rodinal Jay (zorkicat) had a bottle from '05 that was still good. If you are confident with drain cleaner.
 
OP
OP

jim appleyard

Subscriber
Allowing Ads
Joined
Nov 21, 2004
Messages
2,421
Location
glens falls, ny USA
Format
Multi Format
Doubtful. While I'm far from perfect, I'm a very careful darkroom user and I've been doing films in Rodinal for decades and have had no failure until recently. Real Rodinal from Agfa lasted forever and I once got ahold of a old glass bottle with the cork that was half-full. It was fine.

Now my APH09 lasts only a few months and it happens to all the films I dev in it and over the course of 3-4 bottles.

Blast Agfa anyway for going out of business!


Jim,
What is a person suppose to buy that is the closest to good old Agfa Rodinal?????[/QUOTE]

Yeah, mix your own, but I tried this one and din't have good luck. It's an option, but I'd have to re-test all my times and would rather not do that.

Previous posts have suggested to try Adox Rodinal and NOT the APH09 that I've been using. Both are available from Freestyle, APH09 is the cheaper of the two.
 

Xmas

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
6,398
Location
UK
Format
35mm RF
Jim,
What is a person suppose to buy that is the closest to good old Agfa Rodinal?????

Yeah, mix your own, but I tried this one and din't have good luck. It's an option, but I'd have to re-test all my times and would rather not do that.

Previous posts have suggested to try Adox Rodinal and NOT the APH09 that I've been using. Both are available from Freestyle, APH09 is the cheaper of the two.[/QUOTE]
Try
(there was a url link here which no longer exists)
Zorkicat did long term tests +5 years in plastic with his.
His site has been down a while now.
 

tcaddle

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Jul 20, 2010
Messages
4
Location
Seattle, Was
Format
35mm
Yeah, mix your own, but I tried this one and din't have good luck. It's an option, but I'd have to re-test all my times and would rather not do that.

Previous posts have suggested to try Adox Rodinal and NOT the APH09 that I've been using. Both are available from Freestyle, APH09 is the cheaper of the two.
Try
(there was a url link here which no longer exists)
Zorkicat did long term tests +5 years in plastic with his.
His site has been down a while now.[/QUOTE]


Just for informational purposes, attached is the MSDS for Agfa Rodinal from year 1999. You will notice the current offering MSDS is similar in the two primary constituents, but what seems to be missing is the potassium sulfite which is the preservative. Older versions indicate the use of potassium metabisufite as the preservative. Since the current links to MSDS sheets make no mention of a preservative, although one assumes there must be some, thiat may account for the poor keeping quality being experienced.
 

Attachments

  • AGFA Rodinal MSDS.pdf
    861.3 KB · Views: 470

Gerald C Koch

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Jul 12, 2010
Messages
8,131
Location
Southern USA
Format
Multi Format
There are three ways to arrive at the same rodinal concentrate. You can start with potassium sulfite, potassium bisulfite, or potassium metabisulfite. You start with an amount of hydroxide needed to create the phenolate salt of paraminophenol. Then each sulfite requires a different amount of potassium hydroxide but the end product is always the same.

If you want real rodinal then you cannot use drain clearer (lye). The potassium compounds are more active photographically than their sodium equivalents. So stick with the potassium ones across the board. For reasons I have never been able to figure out the potassium salts are cheaper and easier to obtain in Europe. That is why I have never been particularly fond of the homebrew versions made here in the US. Last I looked potassium hydroxide was available from The Chemistry Store. http://www.chemistrystore.com/

There are quite a few rodinal-like developer formulas. But they all have basically the same formula. Per liter of concentrate they contain the equivalent of 50 g of paraminophenol base. For a good recipe follow the following link.

(there was a url link here which no longer exists)
 
Last edited:
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom