Postcard Exchange Round 22 - Comments and Feedback

about to extinct

D
about to extinct

  • 0
  • 0
  • 58
Fantasyland!

D
Fantasyland!

  • 9
  • 2
  • 121
perfect cirkel

D
perfect cirkel

  • 2
  • 1
  • 125
Thomas J Walls cafe.

A
Thomas J Walls cafe.

  • 4
  • 8
  • 303

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
198,748
Messages
2,780,319
Members
99,693
Latest member
lachanalia
Recent bookmarks
1

hpulley

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2010
Messages
2,207
Location
Guelph, Onta
Format
Multi Format
I got two more cards this week, both on glossy Ilford postcard paper which seems to get more wear than the pearl finish. They are:

Lorifrommontana's snowy tree in her yard. With a yard like that you don't have to venture far.

And Mick Fagan's wheat silos. I love silos and elevators. And the Australian landscape looks so interesting compared to what I'm used to.

So I think that's 17 / 20 received. Thanks everyone.
 

rai

Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Messages
81
Format
Multi Format
I have received 20 of the 25 cards, right! are nice, funny, melancolic, suggestive, illustrative ... etc.

Gurkenprinz: funny composition! How many did you take before you decide? I mean the beer ...
George Nova Scotia: a little light that is between two worlds ...
Dave Martiny: I like the white lines with the perfect shades of gray!
Drpsilver: Darwin your nickname always reminds me of "Treasure Island"! beautiful moonlight very well executed!
Laurent: Paris oh! Paris! has a lot of beautiful pictures! Sometimes we forget how beautiful everyday ... beautiful textures full of gray!
Lillian Sly: I like the feeling of cold that renders your card! in my town most of the year's hot!
Moopheus: nice combination of gray and different spellings perfectly executed.
Tim Gray: sharp, well composed, perfect tones and those eyes that remind me of my dog ​​... a griffin with a look very similar.
MattKing: I like the postcard! whenever I see a tree in this situation I get, read and play ... I think as he could finish the history behind! ... although I do not like to hurt anyone!
Rob Skeoch: Woooowwww! beautiful colors! beautiful eyes! beautiful shapes! Do you know the girl? lucky you! and she also ... I guess.
Gordrob: when I got the e-mail cost me see the details! and then wooww! that cold! and they work! beautiful gray!
Lorifrommontana: beautiful, melancholy ride! beautiful tree! perfect composition! in my town only has snowed 7 or 8 times in 50 years! I love snow.
Mick Fagan: are things we see often ... but hold great beauty ... you've captured very well. Perfect composition and beautiful shades of gray.
Oxleyroad: I like to think that the fingerprint belongs to someone while walking thought about something nice. I like the contrast of the stones with sand!
Roger Thoms: bucolic image! well executed! black beautiful downtown area! a classic among classics! I love it!
Mark Rewald: Nice framing! Postal very clear and beautiful sky! I like the tones and makes me want to get in to see what I find!
BlackDog: picture perfect! has almost everything! could be any photography book! I think a lot of fun in the game are different than girls!
Rst pinhole perfect! from darkness to light! good contrast ... good tones ... good subject. I imagine that people walked ah! I like it.
Anikin: yes! much work makes it unique and beautiful! I would have liked to walk through the landscape that skillfully catches!.
Mike Wilde: Three beautiful pictures reminiscent of situations and locations. Very well executed!

I like all I get! there is no postcarad that I dislike! I love these exchanges! thanks everyone!
 

hpulley

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2010
Messages
2,207
Location
Guelph, Onta
Format
Multi Format
I miscounted, I am still expecting 5 cards. This is my first exchange. At what point do we start asking people if they sent cards to see if they didn't make it. Do we do resends in that case?
 

Tim Gray

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Messages
1,882
Location
OH
Format
35mm
I've been in 12 rounds so far, sending out on average about 45 cards per round. Personally, I've never kept track of missing cards, have never asked for missing cards, nor have I ever been asked to send a replacement card. I don't always print up enough extras for replacements anyway, so depending on how the numbers worked out, I might have to pass on sending a replacement.

I figure it's just the nature of the beast.
 

hpulley

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2010
Messages
2,207
Location
Guelph, Onta
Format
Multi Format
That's fine! Just wondered, being my first exchange. Thanks.

Enjoyed every one I've received so far and I suppose I should not worry about the ones not received. Here's hoping a few more show up though :smile:
 

Tim Gray

Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Messages
1,882
Location
OH
Format
35mm
I know some people *do* mail out replacements; you are certainly welcome to. It's just an unmanageable task for me to keep track of who didn't send cards. I always do the max each round so I'm getting 40-50 cards each time, sometimes there's overlap between rounds, and people don't always label which round their cards are for. I figure it's best for me if I don't freak out about any missing cards. Or even to acknowledge that any are missing :wink:
 

Laurent

Subscriber
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
1,829
Location
France
Format
Multi Format
I got a very nice card from Mick Fagan. Great image of silos, the geometry is amazing !

Thanks
 

Roger Thoms

Subscriber
Joined
Nov 18, 2007
Messages
1,773
Location
Flagstaff, AZ
Format
8x10 Format
I'm more than willing resend cards to anyone who did not receive in from me, or received one that was badly mauled. I always print some extras just for this propose. Let me know.

Roger
 

Mick Fagan

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 13, 2005
Messages
4,421
Location
Melbourne Au
Format
Multi Format
Nanette, yes a little bit like the Waikerie ones, although these are as usual on a rail line. Geographically speaking these are almost due east from Waikerie.

I'll be travelling through Waikerie on the SA October long weekend this year to see some friends, I'll have another look at them.

Another reminder of Waikerie is that it was hovering in the low 40's on New Years day this year, when I took that sheet. Hot under the cloth would be an understatement, but there was a boiling hot gentle zephyr blowing to keep sweat off, you know exactly what I mean.

Mick.
 

Mick Fagan

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 13, 2005
Messages
4,421
Location
Melbourne Au
Format
Multi Format
Over the years I have found that emulsions, both colour and B&W, are incredibly resilient to wild temperature fluctuations.

I listened to my late father in-law who was a photographer in WWII in the German army, explain how he at one stage, was operating in -40ºC. The method used was to walk along a trench, stick a TLR upside down overhead and take a shot. Then they walked back to the tent and swapped cameras.

The camera back in the tent was placed near a kerosene lamp to warm up, when it was considered to be around -10ºC the film was very slowly wound on.

The other extreme was with the same cameras and film in Africa, only the temperatures were about 80ºC + different from the Russian front.

I have seen about 3,000 of his photographs from those places and times, film is incredibly resilient.

The day before I took the Silo picture we traveled through 49ºC ambient temperatures at Lake Mungo (google it, it's a world heritage site). I forgot that my film wasn't in the refrigerator that day, at the end of the day. It was just too hot to shoot and the wind was blowing like a blast furnace.

The next day I used a sheet of that film which was stuck inside the camper in a cupboard with an ambient temperature of 49ºC outside, but inferno like inside. The film performed flawlessly as I expected it would.

For those who didn't receive a copy of my silos, the film was 5x4" FP4+.

Mick.
 

hpulley

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2010
Messages
2,207
Location
Guelph, Onta
Format
Multi Format
Thanks for the info, Mick! You might want to upload a scan so the rest can enjoy it too.

The card doesn't say: 5x4" printed onto 6x4", is it just a slight enlargement or a fair crop of the whole scene?
 

Mick Fagan

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 13, 2005
Messages
4,421
Location
Melbourne Au
Format
Multi Format
You are correct, it doesn't say that, but it does say FP4+ 4x5, meaning it's a landscape format using a 5x4" negative. Sorry for the brief description on the label.

The paper, unless I'm wrong, is 100mm by 150mm, not 6x4".

The image is a slight enlargement, as envisaged whilst looking at the ground glass. I find I leave a short bit at all the edges, perhaps 5mm of image that I know I will not print.

Sometimes I leave myself a bit more negative space that I do not intend to print, this is not always my choice, but working with a camera one cannot always get into the best position.

Another aspect in this particular shot, is that the camera viewpoint of the wheat silos were from a low position, this coupled with the wheat silos height, made me use 38mm of front rise. To do this I had to change from a 150 lens to the 215 lens, move slightly further back and use nearly maximum rise.

The 150 lens couldn't give me enough rise, so I switched to the 215mm Ilex which has enormous coverage and gave me the perspective and framing I was after.

I used a Shen Hao 4x5" wooden field camera, exposure was 1/10 at f22.

Due to using the maximum rise that the camera is capable of, there was a very slight bit of a vignetting from the bellows on two corners of the negative. This was understandable and known, when I took the exposure.

The print is a straight print.

I hand wrote and addressed all of the postcards whilst sitting in the middle of nowhere in our camper over Easter, this took a couple of hours and a bit, extremely peaceful to say the least. After doing this, which was immediately after lunch, I then walked down the track a bit and took a sheet of our camper and ute, I developed the negatives last night and may use the shot of our camper and ute for the next round.

This should give you a very different perspective of what Australian grass looks like after the heaviest rain fall year since 1974 and 1956. Normally at this time of the year the grass is either burnt or withered to almost nothing, however at Mt Terrick Terrick state park, the grasslands area was amazing, so were the birds and spiders, to say nothing about the mosquitoes, frogs, snakes and lizards, and kangaroos. I think I saw a fat-tailed-Dunnart, which makes sense as we have had a locust plague through here, they thrive on locusts.

Mick.
 

kraker

Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2005
Messages
1,165
Location
The Netherlands
Format
Multi Format
Mick, I too have received your "wheat silo" card. A great print as always, thanks.

To all:

All my cards (25) were sent some time ago and should have reached their destinations by now. I have a few spare cards this time 'round, so if I was on your list but you haven't received my card, let me know and I'll send another copy.
 

Roger Thoms

Subscriber
Joined
Nov 18, 2007
Messages
1,773
Location
Flagstaff, AZ
Format
8x10 Format
Mick nice job one the Wheat Silo, great image, really like the sky, perfect backdrop for the silos.

Roger
 

Aron

Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2009
Messages
256
Location
Hungary
Format
Multi Format
Dear all participants, I'm deeply sorry it took me such a long time to give feedback. I had a few difficulties during the period of this round, including the old "I can't decide which one of my negatives to print". Most of my new work was experimental and although I believe I learned a lot, because of the nature of these photos, they didn't really turn out well and I was also rather confused about the way I wanted to print them. Luckily a friend of mine helped me in choosing an image to send so I'll hopefully be able to get to printing them next weekend. This time it's going to be printed on RC paper to get the work done in a short time, not to get even less polite. In the meanwhile, here are the cards I've received:

Mick Fagan: A nice photo, with lovely tones. It makes a nice duo with the card you sent for Round 19.

Lori: Congrats on your new home darkroom! Interesting selective focus effect.

Rai: Quite an unusual print for me who's used to more regular strips of negatives. I like how the different images blend together, this works really well here.

Gordrob: A chilly sport indeed, but he seems to do all right.

BlackDog: I like how this photo illustrates the free nature of the moment.

Anikin: A good detail of nature and I really liked the tone of the print.

Vyshemirsky: Another nice detail of nature. Good tonality.

Oxleyroad: I like how this composition balances smaller, playful details and larger elements.

Dave Martiny: A truly appealing tonality which harmonises well with the smooth nature of the plant. Good work.

Meltronic: Your photo was an instant favourite. I like how the dear brings motion in the otherwise static scene. Also the somewhat retro edge pattern was great, it's been a long time since I saw some one cutting them on paper.

George Nova Scotia: I like this composition with the crossing lines in the foreground. I value the luminousity which is not so easy to achieve in a print, great.

Mark Rewald: The portrait format worked well here dividing the foliage, the barn and the sky well.

hpully: I still remember my excitement when I took the first look at this print, nice composition and that great micro contrast is eye-catching.

Azzy: A simple but good photo with good tones.

Seadrive: I keep this one next to my computer on my desktop, it's truly eye-catching. This print just has a suberb quality. A lovely print, thanks!

Marianne: I can imagine how bugs love the numerous little branches of the tree. A great use for the vintage Kodak.

Fleath: This is one of my favourites. Good framing and it looks great on matt paper with selenium. Thank you, Alex.

Rob Skeoch: The first photo I have in my hands taken with this exciting lens. She's a great subject in front of the colourful background.

Mattking: A good capture, I'm happy you spotted it (them).*

Lillian Sky: This photo is relaxing with its smoothness and subject, despite the fact it must have been rather cold out there.

Bex: A great image with a definite atmosphere. Old Tri-X seems to be doing fine, it just reached it's golden age.

Crispin: A nice coastal image, it is rather surprising to look at this Velvia image when I browse through this round's mostly monochrome cards.

Tim Gray: I like how the lines of the sofa and blanket frame Max's head, a good environmental portrait, I like it.

Uwe Pilz: I know the elephant house in the Budapest zoo, I visit it a few times each year. Your embossed signature is always a nice touch, thanks you.

Christan: An excellent capture of the moment. I see your Hungarian is fairly good, appreciated.

Laurent: A great capture, this tiny piece of ice to me resembles a delicate bird.

Kraker: It's not so easy to make the composition interesting with such a superwide, but I definitely think you succeeded. Thanks.

Drpsilver: I like the atmosphere also of this photo. Your card arrived in a slightly weathered condition, with a piece of its surface missing in the centre, but this only adds to the image rather than taking away from it.

Ozphoto: A classic photo which makes me smile every time I look at it.

JohnnyWalker: I like how this photo represents the harmony of nature and man (and family).

Moopheus: Lovely little detail, nice shot.

Greg Coan: Also this photo captures the spirit of summer well.

Craig Cross: A nice, calm landscape. Black borders can sometimes be edgy, but I like them.

Kevin Kehler: I personally don't think this photograph is soft, instead I see a lovely tonal range with delicate highs and mids.

Rüdiger: A very nice composition, I like the ballance of straight lines and curves.

Rtbadman: I like how this image combines softer and stronger qualities.

Mike Wilde: For some reason your envelope arrived to me open (which was put in another envelope by our postal service). I like the fact you sent us three different cards, all on old paper.

Once again, thanks everyone and my apologies for the massive delay. I hope I'm not going to test your patience much further.
 

Laurent

Subscriber
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
1,829
Location
France
Format
Multi Format
Todays card is Wayne Frederick's view of a wooden frame house. The geometry of the house is quite interesting !

Thanks !
 

BirgerA

Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2004
Messages
297
Location
Oslo, Norway
Format
Multi Format
I sent my cards today.
 

piu58

Member
Joined
May 29, 2006
Messages
1,531
Location
Leipzig, Germany
Format
Medium Format
Yesterday I got the most interesting card of this round - Birger's Zebra. I hope you enjoy the image as much as me.
 

rai

Member
Joined
Sep 17, 2007
Messages
81
Format
Multi Format
I also have received yesterday Birger's Zebra, this works for me!
 

MattKing

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
52,873
Location
Delta, BC Canada
Format
Medium Format
I’ve previously commented on the cards I received from 16 people. Since then, I’ve received cards from 8 more APUGers:

gordrob - “Ice Diver” - this photo really made me shiver (that is a good thing!)
lorirfrommontana - “Spring Snow” - thanks Lori for sharing your interesting back yard
markrewald - “Delany Round Barn” - a very nice print - that round barn is set off nicely by a dramatic sky
Mick Fagan - “Wheat Silo Merinee Victoria” - it looks so hot! - a really nice, full range print
rai - “Carre Sainte Anne, Montpellier” - a really inventive and intriguing multi-image card
rtbadman - “Panoche Valley, California” - I really like the sharpness and image tone
seadrive - “Rocks and Grass, Dam Pond” - so sharp, it almost bites
Tim Gray - “Max” - Great portrait (it is the eyes, you know :smile:)

24 down, 4 (Aron, BirgerA, Black Dog and HowardDvorin) to go :smile:

Thanks to everyone for participating.
 

kraker

Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2005
Messages
1,165
Location
The Netherlands
Format
Multi Format
Received Birger's Zebra. Very nice print. Easy to guess the subject, even though the viewer only sees a detail. I like it, thanks.
 

Laurent

Subscriber
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
1,829
Location
France
Format
Multi Format
I received Birger's zebra last Saturday. Great image !
 
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom