Ian, I think you are right. I have a package of XR-1 and it certainly has more chemicals in it than the formula indicates. I'll have to locate it and check its weight.
From the patent disclosure,
Using a Nikon 55 Millimeter Micro camera and 35 millimeter Eastman Kodak High Contrast Copy film, two groups containing 36 exposures each were made at each of the following speeds: ASA 12, ASA 25, and ASA 50. All exposures were made at a lens opening of f/11, and all were made outdoors on a bright, sunny day. Each exposure included brightly lit areas, areas including varying degrees of shadow detail, a number of signs bearing printed material of various sizes and colors and clear, blue sky in the background to examine and evaluate film grain. The two groups were developed in developers containing the following compositions:
INGREDIENT A B
1-phenyl-3-pyrazolidone 1.50 1.75
hydroquinone 0.50 0.25
p-methylaminophenolsulfate 0.25 0.25
sodium sulfite 30.00 30.00
borax 0.75 0.50
water (distilled) to make 1 liter to make 1 liter
The ASA 25 exposures exhibited resolving power in the order of 90 to 200 linear lines per millimeter, an extremely high degree of sharpness, and the full scale of well-defined gray tones from absolute white to complete black. All colors were recorded in an appropriate shade of gray and were accurately reproduced. A contrast ratio was obtained which enabled prints to be made on Grade No. 2 enlarging paper. Grain was undetectable in prints enlarged to 8 by 10 inches in size. No sacrifice in quality was observed in prints measuring 20 by 30 inches, which represents magnification of approximately 20 times the original negative size. Similar results were obtained from negatives made from exposures at ASA 12 except for a slight loss on the highlight end of the gray scale and a one paper grade increase in contrast. Negatives made at ASA 50 exhibited a slight loss of shadow area detail and a one paper grade decrease in contrast.