Horatio
Subscriber
This is the exact reason I quit using D-23. Mixed myself and replenished (with DK-25R), it was almost free to process, a few cents a roll, but I didn't like the mushy grain.
Haven't had Xtol running long enough to pixel-peep much yet, but despite similar sulfite levels to D-23 or D-76, I don't see that "mushiness" with Xtol (stock). End of the day, though, (Pa)Rodinal gives you whatever grain your film already had, no modifications. If you don't like the grain you're getting in Rodinal or work-alike, try a different film.
Donald, just curious about whether you still use Parodinal, and if so, whether its grain properties differ from straight Rodinal. Second, is it possible to make Parodinal by adding tylenol to regular Rodinal?
Edit: Nevermind. After more reading, I now see that the tylenol is not an added ingredient, but a different way to produce the original formula. Chemistry was not one of my better subjects back in the day.
Last edited: