Dear Michael,
I think you hit it on the head with the key statement 'the students do not wish to give it up' we hear this time and time again, students spend so much time in front of their computers the act of physically creating your image and print is something different, exciting, truly creative and satisfying...its all part of why HARMAN and our Chairman Howard Hopwood started 'the defend the darkroom' project...
The skills taught and acquired by using and understanding silver based photography are fundamental in making a photographer and or printer, regardless of whether in your career you carry on to use mostly digital photography.
We also see people on APUG who started out with digital and have worked back to silver as their interest in photography needs to find a true and unique expression, I do bang on about it, and I know it is my livelyhood, but silver photography is a very, very important part of our world culture, east and west, north and south and must be championed and the best advocates of all are those that teach and those that are willing to share knowledge, its why we especially support APUG.
We work with colleges around the world to promote silver based teaching, and all to often we hear of decisions being taken about closing darkrooms because they can fund computers but not sinks and enlargers, and that health and safety legislation makes it easier to go inkjet.....and its easier to have a dry area than a wet area...
People say its more expensive, perhaps so, but when you look at the cost of inkjet media , ink, printers, service, and more significantly the endless built in obsolescence of computers and digital imaging devices I think silver remains good value for money in the long term..
Well, in my opinion, if you are going to make a real photographer, he or she will need to get their hands wet sometime, so do it in college and have them taught properly and safely.
You cannot teach an art student to paint on a computer...nor a photographer...
Also do not call me ( us ? ) luddites, I have no problem with digital photography whatsoever it has some great applications that enhance photography, but as well as, not... instead of...
Simon ILFORD Photo / HARMAN technology Limited :