Is the Ebay market hurting new film sales?

[benjiboy]

I must be the only person on this forum who hasn't an e bay account and has never bought anything on it. I use Fuji film and buy it on line direct from Fuji UK, I don't find the prices too bad, and they have some good special offers

 

[Athiril]

IMHO the prices on Fleabay for proper in date film are excessive compared to even high street sources in the UK.

Anyone who thinks that ebay is a reliable source of bargains these days is to put it honestly a bit optimistic

Superia 100 in 120 can be had for $3.36AUD/roll, Provia 100f 120 about $5.60/roll. They are absolute bargains. While it may be possible to get it cheaper in the UK or US, this is the absolute cheapest price available to an Australian, freestyle, B&H and others rip us off big time with the shipping charges (start at $40 to $50 U.S. - which is a rip off, Ive had someone send me heavier bigger stuff for much less).

The most expensive roll of film I've seen here in a shop was about $35 to $40, Provia 400X in 35mm.

100 AUD for a litre of HC-110 concentrate?

Tom

Last I checked Vanbar does not stock or even sell HC-110, therefore getting it will be a pain, and quite expensive, even if anywhere else in Australia does sell it.

Vanbar is expensive when compared to UK and US places, but in reality its cheap and stocks a superb range in comparison to any other Australian supplier, all others are just rip offs in chems and other things, and don't stock or sell anything other than the absolute basics.

 

[Pupfish]

Hell's bell's, I bought Quickloads new at full retail from MPEX last fall which turned out to be expired (and they didn't exactly fall all over themselves to remedy the situation). Being that it was Fujicolor Pro160s it was fine, I might add.

Would I have rather paid 1/2 price and known that it was expired ahead of that surprise discovery? You betcha!

Next question-- will I ever buy anything from MPEX ever again?

The traditional bricks and mortar businesses are hurting for a variety of reasons, not just eBay.

 

[Thomas Bertilsson]

I think sometimes good purchases can be made on eBay, and I have done so in the past when my finances didn't allow fresh film, which was often.

After a few years of shooting expired film with varying results, I decided it was false economy to continue. So I forced myself to shoot less film and always buy fresh. It costs more initially, but the results are consistent, and I know what to expect.

What I have seen lately, though, is that when I do pop into the auction site, just for giggles, I see prices of film that are pretty high! It's close to that of Freestyle, especially if you go for their inexpensive private label film, like Legacy Pro or the 'faux Kodak' stuff. So to me it doesn't make sense anymore. It is a bit of a crap shoot to buy expired film.

To answer the original question - I think it does maybe hurt the fresh film market, but it's natural that it occurs. You might argue that it would be a waste to just dispose of the film without using it, even if it's old. And if it's cheaper, obviously some photographers don't mind paying less for something that is a bit of a risk quality wise. Supply and demand. The old expired film wouldn't be sold unless there was a market for it.
And, it's good with competition for the fresh film suppliers. Without competition the prices might be even higher than they are on fresh film.

Buy what you can afford, (and that could mean to shoot less and still buy fresh), and go make some pictures!

 

[eclarke]

I don't know what Kodak, Ilford or Fuji's full film coating capacity is/was but I'm sure it is millions and millions of square yards of product. I don't think eBay film sales are even a blip in comparison...Ec

 

[Zuikopath]

I too find the Ebay prices too high for regular stuff - it's useful for occasional film oddities that pop up out of grandma's drawers but otherwise I prefer to use online retailers of fresh stock.

A quick Google search often reveals a dealer selling fresh stock for a lower price than the 'bargain' Ebay film you just found

 

[Moopheus]

I don't know what Kodak, Ilford or Fuji's full film coating capacity is/was but I'm sure it is millions and millions of square yards of product. I don't think eBay film sales are even a blip in comparison...Ec

A quick browse of completed film sales would seem to back this up--eBay is probably selling a few hundred rolls a month, and a lot of it is really old stuff, even films that are out of production (I myself recently scored some Super XX and Ilford FP4). Even in today's film market eBay's quantities are likely pretty trivial, not enough to affect anybody's production.

 

[railwayman3]

I don't know what Kodak, Ilford or Fuji's full film coating capacity is/was but I'm sure it is millions and millions of square yards of product. I don't think eBay film sales are even a blip in comparison...Ec

Quite a lot of film on UK Ebay is normal fresh stock being sold as "Buy it Now" from regular mail order dealers....prices are not much less than retail, so that's really no different from normal sales, just another way of selling.

There's some out-of-date stuff, usually from private sellers selling just one-or-two spare films, as you say not even a blip in the scheme of things.

There actually seemed more bargains two or three years ago, when you could get in-date films at good prices...perhaps that was when people were changing to the dark side and emptying their fridges.

 

[swhiser]

"Is the Ebay market hurting new film sales?"

It's tempting to dismiss the question but the issue of film sales is interesting as well as important.

The answer to the question is 'no', regardless of the size of the eBay market.

eBay is a gray market mixed with an above-ground market. Call it a hybrid retail markt. Accordingly, demand for new and expired film on eBay reflects overall demand for film. Prices for both kinds of film on eBay are governed by the total market.

In no way should any individual feel compelled against or guilty for buying there, as it takes the respective units out of the broader inventory at a given price. It is what it is: supply. All use of film is good (apart from environmental impacts).

If the question is, 'How can we help keep the films we love in production?' that is an interesting question that maybe addresses our concerns more precisely. If there is not enough demand for film or for a particular film (that is produced with particular machines in a particular place), a manufacturer would be stupid to produce it out of charity.

We are seeing the discontinuation of important films by the big manufacturers, but the smaller factories are benefiting from this contraction of capacity.

I too would love to see worldwide sales trends. Ilford has this information but don't share it. The fact that they -- with their strong commitment to black & white -- and their new investments in direct positive papers (and a Walker pinhole camera to go with it) as well as their new Art 300 paper, these should be strongly positive implications that the overall numbers are positive.

Just because Kodak and Fuji are closing capacity -- and likely to close more -- this is not an indication that film overall is going away. Some of these capacity reductions will be painful. But scale in certain places is no longer supported by reality.

 

[pentaxuser]

What all the other U.K based posters have said. We have good retailers of which AgPhotographic is but one who beat e-bay consistently.

pentaxuser

 

[CGW]

It's bottom-feeding. It's yard sale film. Steady price hikes for film encourage it but pro demand for film materials tanked at 5-7 years ago with few still shooting film now as their main capture medium--the main reason film sales went over the falls. That leaves amateurs, hobbyists, survivalists, contrarians, hard-cores--pretty much the APUG profile, no?

I've bought short and stale dated film at local semi-annual swaps meets. Who can resist a buck a roll? It's f-around film. There's still quite a bit in my film fridge/freezer. Available supplies are thinning and getting crazy old. Those pros mentioned upstream sold their film stashes years ago.

If I want consistency and the occasional check, I buy and shoot new stuff.

 

[brianmquinn]

A lot of time when I buy cheap film on ebay or such I shoot more of it. It may hurt film sales a bit but it helps keeps the labs running. We really need both.

For chrome I alway buy new. I just placed an order for 50 rolls.

 

[PKM-25]

In years past when I was creating a working stash of films like Kodachrome 25, Techpan and APX 25, I used eBay. Now that I have plentiful supplies of discontinued films I need in deep freeze, I only buy from Freestyle or B&H.

I know there is a lot of talk of pros abandoning film but don't you think that is a little of a blanket statement? I know plenty who have gone back to it for personal reasons even on paying jobs. Sometimes I feel like this site is mostly people who like to dabble in the technical side of photography, to fondle and load film cameras but don't get outside that much.

It's a big world outside of this here Internet and you might be surprised at what you find if you look...

 

[CGW]

"I know there is a lot of talk of pros abandoning film but don't you think that is a little of a blanket statement? I know plenty who have gone back to it for personal reasons even on paying jobs. Sometimes I feel like this site is mostly people who like to dabble in the technical side of photography, to fondle and load film cameras but don't get outside that much.

It's a big world outside of this here Internet and you might be surprised at what you find if you look... "

Where have you been? Ever puzzle out why "pro" labs thinned out or vanished altogether across much of N. America? Could it just possibly be that "pros" were no longer processing the miles of film they once shot? Not sure about the "pros" you know but the ones in my world ditched film altogether 5-8 years ago and never looked back.