i have asked him to scan and email a copy to post. The strangest thing is where they are found, it is not bromide drag. It isn't a result of the film touching during the process, and they aren't found on the entire roll or on any of the other rolls developed at the same time just in the middle of the roll.
I told him to remix and wash right way, but my sense is he went his own way, and sense this is not a class for credit there isn't much i can do except recommend and go over procedures . Some people just are stubborn and ,,,,,,,,,,,
patterson reels, hc110 solution b kodak stop bath ilford fix 1:3. time of fix should be 5min with inverted agitation once every 30 seconds. the usual basic method. i am not in the darkroom with them at this stage of the class when developing film so to the speed of filling, and other areas of this sort i can't comment. I know what was taught and demonstrated, but unless i am standing next to them while they process their film it is hard to know. I am there the first few times they develop film, but then they are on their own for that process.
it will be interesting to see if it occurs again and with another student.
in my 67 years of doing darkroom work i have probably made every mistake in the book and out of the book but never had seen this.
thanks for the suggestions and input