How to remove hardened fixer

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
178,699
Messages
2,458,267
Members
94,614
Latest member
Martin C
Recent bookmarks
0

RalphLambrecht

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 19, 2003
Messages
12,971
Location
K,Germany
Shooter
Medium Format
I used the search engine, but did find the right thread.

What is the latest opinion on how to remove the hardened fixer residue on storage bottles?

I tried warm water and also 25% vinegar, but neither worked very well.

What has worked for you?
 

bill williams

Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2005
Messages
73
Shooter
35mm
I can look it up later if you can't find it, but I believe that the Kodak tray cleaner formula does a great job of cleaning everything. It has sulfuric acid and potassium permanganate in it I believe, and then finish off with a sodium sulfite solution.
 

PeteZ8

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
408
Location
Newtown, PA
Shooter
Medium Format
Interesting Bill. Must not be a strong mixture, as sulphuric acid and potassium permanganate can be highly unstable and explosive!
 

bill williams

Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2005
Messages
73
Shooter
35mm
I know. It is a Kodak formula, it is very dilute. Potassium permanganate and a lot of things make for lots of heat. Pouring a little glycerin into a small pile of Potassium permanganate makes for a very neat hot lave experiment.

The Kodak tray cleaner is what I use for b&w and color bottle and tray cleaning, and it works very well. You just need to take precautions and work carefully to mix it up, as with most anything photographic or otherwise. Common Sense. I usually buy a quart of battery acid from the NAPA store, the P.P. from Home Depot. Keep them both inside double zip lock freezer bags and in separate small plastic paint cans outside. I've done so for years and never had any misfortune of an accident. I think IIRC the battery acid is about 56% acid. I don't think you can find anything that cleans as well.
 

bill williams

Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2005
Messages
73
Shooter
35mm
Kodak TC-3

Tray Cleaner

Solution A
Water 1 liter
Potassium Permanganate 2 grams or about 1/4 tsp
Sulfuric Acid 4 ml (photo grade) or 10 ml of battery acid

Solution B
Water 750 ml
Sodium Bisulfite 30 grams
Sodium Sulfite 30 grams
Water To Make 1 liter

Use solution A first, and then rinse with B. Final rinse in
Tap water. I actually dilute A and B further, about 4
parts water to 1 part a or b.
 

Photo Engineer

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 19, 2005
Messages
29,033
Location
Rochester, NY
Shooter
Multi Format
If the white stain is sulfur from decomposed fix, there is little that will dissolve it. I have had some success using 50% Sodium Hydroxide solution as a bottle rinse followed by a good water wash and a scrub with a bottle brush.

Take great care with the Sodium Hydroxide as it generates a lot of heat when mixed with water or diluted.

I have heard that some have had success using Di Methyl Formamide.

PE
 
Last edited by a moderator:

PeteZ8

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2008
Messages
408
Location
Newtown, PA
Shooter
Medium Format
I know. It is a Kodak formula, it is very dilute. Potassium permanganate and a lot of things make for lots of heat. Pouring a little glycerin into a small pile of Potassium permanganate makes for a very neat hot lave experiment.

The Kodak tray cleaner is what I use for b&w and color bottle and tray cleaning, and it works very well. You just need to take precautions and work carefully to mix it up, as with most anything photographic or otherwise. Common Sense. I usually buy a quart of battery acid from the NAPA store, the P.P. from Home Depot. Keep them both inside double zip lock freezer bags and in separate small plastic paint cans outside. I've done so for years and never had any misfortune of an accident. I think IIRC the battery acid is about 56% acid. I don't think you can find anything that cleans as well.

Someone gave me a small bottle of P.P.; I have yet to play with it. Looks like it could have lots of useful applications though. I did not realize it was sold at Home Depot. Where would I find it there? Is it sold as P.P. or under a brand name? I noticed they stopped selling muratic (hydrochloric) acid, or at least in the stores I have been in. I wonder how many other "dangerous" chemicals they have pulled.

If you're brave enough, the sulphuric acid could easily be distilled back to a higher purity. That is, of course, if you wanted to use it for something "other" than cleaning things :wink: While I have yet to try it, brake fluid (polyethelyne glycol) is also supposed to have a rather, uh, strong exothermic reaction similar to the glycerine.

Note to anyone wishing to mix sulphuric acid with P.P.; if mixed with enough purity, it is such a powerful oxidizer that it will literally explode on contact with any fuel source. It will also produce toxic ozone, not something you really want to be doing inside.
 

ic-racer

Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Messages
12,279
Location
USA
Shooter
Multi Format
Nothing. I tried acetone, soap, laquer thinner. I got a little result from isopropyl alchohol, but probably just my rubbing did more good. I was trying to clean a large open-top container, so I was able to get my hands down in there and scrub. It never came completely clean.
 

Photo Engineer

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 19, 2005
Messages
29,033
Location
Rochester, NY
Shooter
Multi Format
The sulfuric acid we get here as battery acid is about 37% based on Specific Gravity.

Permanganates react and explode or catch fire in contact with some chemicals such as glycerine.

PE
 

bill williams

Member
Joined
Mar 11, 2005
Messages
73
Shooter
35mm
Sold at Home Depot, "Filter-Mate Potassium Permanganate, Green Sand Iron Filter Regenerator". Absolutely be sure you read up on any chemical before you use it. As I said, P.P. will react with a large list of other items, generating lots of heat. A small pile of P.P., say maybe an ounce or so, and about a quarter of an ounce of glycerine poured into it will make a small lava flow, glowing, flaming, smoking. And of course battery acid is not to be treated carelessly either. HOWEVER, I've never had any problem mixing up the tray cleaner or using it. As always, mix the ingredients in the order they are in the formula. Wearing gloves and eye protection is highly recommended. Once its all mixed up, its not really that powerful, and in fact is pretty weak. It does clean trays very well.
 

jeroldharter

Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2005
Messages
1,956
Location
Wisconsin
Shooter
4x5 Format
Does the fixer residue hurt anything?

I suppose if it is that hard to dissolve it shouldn't be a contaminate during processing. I do hate those spots though.
 

dancqu

Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2002
Messages
3,654
Location
Willamette V
Shooter
Medium Format
To Date the Very Latest This Thread

What is the latest opinion on how to remove the hardened
fixer residue on storage bottles?

I believe Hydrogen Peroxide will convert the sulfured sulfite
into sulfate and perhaps sulfur. Sulfite will convert sulfur
into thiosulfate.

You've likely both on hand. If you give the two a try be
careful, there may be side effects. Ammonia and H2O2?
Warming may be a big help.

Not a problem for myself. Fresh, a sessions worth at
time of processing. Dan
 
OP
OP
RalphLambrecht

RalphLambrecht

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 19, 2003
Messages
12,971
Location
K,Germany
Shooter
Medium Format
Does the fixer residue hurt anything?

I suppose if it is that hard to dissolve it shouldn't be a contaminate during processing. I do hate those spots though.

It has to go, or I have to replace the bottles. The fixer has settled at the bottom of the bottle and does not come off with water alone. But frequently, small particles come lose when pouring. These particles are hard as rock and can cling to the soft emulsion.

I've started a test to find out which suggestion works best. I placed several drops of fixer onto a glass plate and will try to remove them once they have dried. For some reason, the drying process seems to take forever. After 12 hours there is no sign of them drying yet.
 
OP
OP
RalphLambrecht

RalphLambrecht

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 19, 2003
Messages
12,971
Location
K,Germany
Shooter
Medium Format
Hair blower?

I don't think this will remove the hardened fixer. :smile:

No, no, this is part of the experiment now. I always thought spilled fixer had to be cleaned up immediately, but it looks like there is plenty of time to do so.
 
OP
OP
RalphLambrecht

RalphLambrecht

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 19, 2003
Messages
12,971
Location
K,Germany
Shooter
Medium Format
I used the search engine, but did find the right thread.

What is the latest opinion on how to remove the hardened fixer residue on storage bottles?

I tried warm water and also 25% vinegar, but neither worked very well.

What has worked for you?

getting new bottles!
 

Gerald C Koch

Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2010
Messages
8,141
Location
Southern USA
Shooter
Multi Format
It sounds like what you have is not hardened fixer as this would be soluble in hot water. I would guess that you have elemental sulfur which is insoluble in water. Sulfur will dissolve in a solution of sodium sulfide. What is formed is a soluble polysulfide.
 

paul ron

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2004
Messages
2,671
Location
NYC
Shooter
Medium Format
I second the get new bottles. They are cheap enough considering how long it lasts.

.
 

Gerald C Koch

Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2010
Messages
8,141
Location
Southern USA
Shooter
Multi Format
Never, never, NEVER mix potassium permangante with concentrated sulfuric acid. What you get is manganese heptoxide a very powerful oxidizer and unstable compound. I can't believe that there are websites telling people how to make this chemical. A professor at a school I attended accidently made a small amount in a 50 ml beaker. After it exploded no one could find any trace of the beaker. It was literally pulverized. Fortunately no one was injuted as the beaker was in a lab sink which acted as a blast shield.

One of the first things taught to chemistry students is never mix any chemicals together unless you know what is going to happen. Even then you must use the upmost care.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Rick A

Subscriber
Joined
Mar 31, 2009
Messages
9,059
Location
Laurel Highlands
Shooter
Large Format
Definitly sounds like time for new bottles. I know, we all acquire attachments to our "favorite" items, but sometimes you just have to replace them.
 

ic-racer

Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Messages
12,279
Location
USA
Shooter
Multi Format
What has worked for you?

Nothing!

I recently cleaned my drum-style fixer container with spigot. I tired the following without success:

70% isopropyl
98% isopropyl
Denatured ethanol
Naptha
Concentrated fresh fixer
Acetic acid
Laquer thinner
Mineral spirits
Soap and water

I wound up just scraping most of the residue off with a "Chore Boy".
 

cowanw

Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2006
Messages
1,982
Location
Hamilton, On
Shooter
Large Format
I once had what I presumed was a silver compound from overused fixer, plating out on the surface of nalgeen bottles. physical scrubbing was the only solution to removing it. It came off in flakes.
 
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab
Top Bottom