It is most likely a safelight issue. Yellow is not good for variable contrast papers. Kodak "OC" or equivalent is the absolute minimum requirement. I use red myself, and though that probably is a bit of overkill, it is safe for the ortho-lith films I use and I'm too lazy to be changing out safelight filters when I change materials. Exposure is cumulative, so while a short period of exposure under the yellow safelight might be ok, over time the other sheets in the box are accumulating exposure each time it's opened. As for storing the paper without the black plastic bag, that's no good. The cardboard boxes or envelopes are not necessarily light tight, nor were they designed to be.