Help with using a Polarizing filter

Curved Wall

A
Curved Wall

  • 3
  • 0
  • 60
Crossing beams

A
Crossing beams

  • 9
  • 1
  • 79
Shadow 2

A
Shadow 2

  • 3
  • 0
  • 57
Shadow 1

A
Shadow 1

  • 3
  • 0
  • 55
Darkroom c1972

A
Darkroom c1972

  • 3
  • 2
  • 102

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
198,837
Messages
2,781,626
Members
99,722
Latest member
Backfocus
Recent bookmarks
0

Paarl2195

Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2022
Messages
4
Location
New Zealand
Format
35mm
Hi, I recently bought a Tiffen polarizing filter for my Canon AE-1. I developed a roll after I have been using it and I have found the images that came out to be quite dull/exposed incorrectly. I am trying to find out what I have been doing wrong when using the filter. I meter images using the camera's internal meter. When I place the filter on, the light is decreased by 1 or 2 stops. I have been reducing (lengthening) the shutter speed when taking a shot, to compensate for the reduced light. Is this the right process? I have attached some images to demonstrate what I mean, any help appreciated!
 

Attachments

  • SM25632_SM25632-R2-012-4A.jpg
    SM25632_SM25632-R2-012-4A.jpg
    792.9 KB · Views: 129
  • SM25632_SM25632-R1-074-35A.jpg
    SM25632_SM25632-R1-074-35A.jpg
    810 KB · Views: 139
  • SM25632_SM25632-R2-018-7A.jpg
    SM25632_SM25632-R2-018-7A.jpg
    911.1 KB · Views: 133

runswithsizzers

Subscriber
Joined
Jan 19, 2019
Messages
1,758
Location
SW Missouri, USA
Format
Multi Format
What do the negatives look like?

Does your polarizing filter say: "CPL" or "Circular" on it? The metering system on some cameras might be affected by polarized light, and those cameras must use newer circular polarizing filters rather than the older linear ones. The first thing I would want to determine is if the negatives are correctly exposed (more-or-less). So try to photograph the negatives on a light box or taped to a window, and post results.

EDIT: Actually, now that I think about it - I don't think the metering system cares if the polarizing filter is linear or circular. I was confused; it may be the autofocus systems that were affected, and not the autoexposure systems.
 
Last edited:

runswithsizzers

Subscriber
Joined
Jan 19, 2019
Messages
1,758
Location
SW Missouri, USA
Format
Multi Format
[...] I meter images using the camera's internal meter. When I place the filter on, the light is decreased by 1 or 2 stops. I have been reducing (lengthening) the shutter speed when taking a shot, to compensate for the reduced light. Is this the right process? [...]

Yes, it is normal for the polarizing filter to require 1.5 to 2.5-stops more exposure. But your Canon AE-1 offers through the lens metering, so if you are using the camera's auto exposure function (AE), then there is no need to do anything else. That is, the Canon's shutter-priority AE system will automatically increase the aperture to provide the needed extra exposure.

If, however, you are metering manually, then yes, decreasing shutter speed (increasing exposure time) is needed to get the correct exposure as indicated by the Canon's match-needle, stopped down metering.
 

Helge

Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2018
Messages
3,938
Location
Denmark
Format
Medium Format
Does the wrongly exposed photos include sky? The AE-1 metering is rather primitive and can be fooled by non obvious things.
Also the sky varies wildly in brightness over the day with a polarizer (there is a traveling band “opposite” the sun through the day).

The filter can also introduce a slight colour cast and the metering cell might be less sensitive to
Either end of the spectrum.

Finally is the possibility that the polarizer simply to your eyes dulls the image. It can take out highlights in leaves, ground and buildings that might be mistaken for underexposure.

Of course check the metering.
Is compensation accidentally set?
Does the meter match a known accurate meter on a sunlit wall?
Is it consistent from day to day without the filter (clear blue sky at noon is a pretty consistent absolute)?
 

tokam

Subscriber
Joined
Nov 7, 2008
Messages
586
Location
Sydney, Aust
Format
Multi Format
I used a plain polariser with an AE-1 for a number of years. It even worked in NZ :smile:. As @runswithsizzers said, the shutter priority auto exposure system will open up the aperture to compensate. Just make sure that you don't run out of aperture values at the wide end. If your exposure calls for an aperture greater than the largest aperture on your lens, the AE-1 will flash a warning in the lower right hand corner of the viewfinder and the meter needle will be at the bottom of the scale. The AE-1 will still fire the shutter in this case and your shots will be underexposed.

Most of the Canon FD cameras could use a plain polariser with the exception of the T90 and possibly the F1-N.
 

MattKing

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
52,939
Location
Delta, BC Canada
Format
Medium Format
IIRC, the test of whether circular polarizer was required with a manual focus film camera turned on whether the camera used a beam splitter to divert a portion of the light for metering purposes.
I don't think that the AE-1 did.
 

foc

Subscriber
Joined
Jun 30, 2010
Messages
2,519
Location
Sligo, Ireland
Format
35mm
A polarising filter works best when the light source (the sun) is at a 90 degree angle to the camera, in other words to your side.
If the light comes from behind you or from in front of you then it will have no effect, like what appears in your 3rd photo taken from the riverbank. You can see what appears to be the sun reflecting in the water.
The easiest way to see the effect of a polarising filter is to turn it while looking through the viewfinder. If the sky / tree foliage / water changes from bright to dark, then you know you have the right light angle.
As has been said, the Canon should meter correctly with the filter in place but depending on how the filter is rotated and the light angle your image can appear bright or dark.
 

AgX

Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2007
Messages
29,973
Location
Germany
Format
Multi Format
I only buy used filters. And amongst those I came across so far practically the only ones with issues were polarizers. These can deteriorate, showing a haze. Such might explain the result.

A good polarizer is perfectly clear, though with reduced transmission, thus greyish.
 

Jim Jones

Subscriber
Joined
Jan 16, 2006
Messages
3,740
Location
Chillicothe MO
Format
Multi Format
A polarizing filter consists of two flat glass plates sandwiching a thin layer of polarizing material. Over many years I've had this complex sandwich (Nikon) deform in extreme environments and for the polarizing film (Leica) to loose it's polarizing ability around its edges.
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2017
Messages
9,457
Location
New Jersey formerly NYC
Format
Multi Format
A polarizing filter consists of two flat glass plates sandwiching a thin layer of polarizing material. Over many years I've had this complex sandwich (Nikon) deform in extreme environments and for the polarizing film (Leica) to loose it's polarizing ability around its edges.
What's nice about my Nikon polarizer is that there's a stop in the outer ring. It helps you to screw it off the lens as you can grab the whole filter to do it both the moveable and unmoveable rings). Other polarizers I have don't have that feature making it harder to remove.
 

tezzasmall

Member
Joined
Dec 29, 2013
Messages
1,135
Location
Southend on Sea Essex UK
Format
Plastic Cameras
A polarising filter works best when the light source (the sun) is at a 90 degree angle to the camera, in other words to your side.
My first thought too, in that it looks like the camera was pointed almost directly at the sun, so probably a bit of flare lowering the contrast.

As you say, you need to have the sun at the right angle to the camera, otherwise the filter won't do anything noticeable.

Terry S
 

pbromaghin

Subscriber
Joined
Sep 30, 2010
Messages
3,807
Location
Castle Rock, CO
Format
Multi Format
Hi, I recently bought a Tiffen polarizing filter for my Canon AE-1.

I have a stupid question, the equivalent of "Is your computer plugged in?". Yes, in my dark, distant past I did spend time at a help desk.

Is this the first time you have ever used a polarizing filter? if so, did you know that the effect changes as the filter is rotated? That you have to rotate it while looking through the camera to get the maximum effect?
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2017
Messages
9,457
Location
New Jersey formerly NYC
Format
Multi Format
My first thought too, in that it looks like the camera was pointed almost directly at the sun, so probably a bit of flare lowering the contrast.

As you say, you need to have the sun at the right angle to the camera, otherwise the filter won't do anything noticeable.

Terry S
The 90-degree point is when the polarizing effect is at its maximum. There's actually a gradation taking place from 0 (180) degrees to 90 degrees where the fall off of the effect operates. Otherwise, you'd just have a hard line of the effect at 90 degrees.

You also have to be careful using polarizers with wide-angle lenses. That gradation will be very noticeable because you'll see the sky from its lighter minimum to darker maximum effect. Either shoot less of the sky or switch to a less wide-angle lens so you're only shooting a smaller part of the sky. That way you won't see the gradation.
 
OP
OP

Paarl2195

Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2022
Messages
4
Location
New Zealand
Format
35mm
Hi thanks all for the replies. I definitely was pointing the camera at towards the sun, so that's definitely an error I'll fix. In terms of the shutter speed, I'll try experimenting with opening the aperture instead of increasing the shitter speed and see the results. This is the first time I have used a polarizer which is why I'm confused.
 

Sirius Glass

Subscriber
Joined
Jan 18, 2007
Messages
50,364
Location
Southern California
Format
Multi Format
Specular refection only can come from man made items and a polarizer will cut down its intensity.
 

Light Capture

Advertiser
Joined
Feb 5, 2008
Messages
217
Location
Ontario, Canada
Format
Multi Format
In addition to different obviously hazy polarizers I had one Tiffen that looked good but produced identical results as your samples.
As said earlier polarizers can deteriorate over time.
You can shoot handheld through it with cellphone or digital camera to confirm.
 

AgX

Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2007
Messages
29,973
Location
Germany
Format
Multi Format
Specular refection only can come from man made items and a polarizer will cut down its intensity.

Already a raindrop, puddle, lake, river, the sea yields specular reflection.
The eye, any body fluid some vegetabile fluids and chitin surfaces too.
Also some minerals, at least at fresh fractures.

The more one thinks, the more natural specular surfaces come to mind...
 

randyB

Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
534
Location
SE Mid-Tennessee, USA
Format
Multi Format
Perhaps you haven't fully realized how a polarizer works, may I suggest a book that might help. You have an 80's era camera, a very good camera that has a lot of features. An 80's era photo book designed to advance beginning photographers to a higher level of photography was the "Joy of Photography" and the sequel "More Joy of Photography". They might be hard to find in NZ, check flea markets, antique stores, used book sellers, etc. They cover many of the techniques that directly relate to your era of camera. Of course, there are many, many other find books that teach the basics. RB
 
OP
OP

Paarl2195

Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2022
Messages
4
Location
New Zealand
Format
35mm
In addition to different obviously hazy polarizers I had one Tiffen that looked good but produced identical results as your samples.
As said earlier polarizers can deteriorate over time.

That's what's concerning me, as this was a brand new Polarizer that I was using for the first time, so I'm hoping its not a faulty product.
 

Light Capture

Advertiser
Joined
Feb 5, 2008
Messages
217
Location
Ontario, Canada
Format
Multi Format
That's what's concerning me, as this was a brand new Polarizer that I was using for the first time, so I'm hoping its not a faulty product.

If polarizer was new, it could also be an issue with a hazy day. Can be invisible to the eye but there can be a lot of UV pollution in the air.
Film will pick it up. Almost all digital sensors will have built in filter in front of them. Some of my shots were definitely affected on some sunny days.
If you didn't have a UV filter on your lens that might be the cause.
Older uncoated and single coated lenses are also more susceptible to UV. So it would also depend on the lens used to some extent.

You can still test your polarizer with cellphone by shooting something indoors. If it looks good, it's not polarizer. Bad polarizer will put wail equally on every image (it might or might not still have some polarizing properties).
 

Sirius Glass

Subscriber
Joined
Jan 18, 2007
Messages
50,364
Location
Southern California
Format
Multi Format
Specular refection only can come from man made items and a polarizer will cut down its intensity.

Already a raindrop, puddle, lake, river, the sea yields specular reflection.
The eye, any body fluid some vegetabile fluids and chitin surfaces too.
Also some minerals, at least at fresh fractures.

The more one thinks, the more natural specular surfaces come to mind...

CORRECTION: I used the wrong term, not "specular reflection", I meant "glint" is a refection of man-made objects that polarization handles differently in that it can completely remove or partially remove.
 

benjiboy

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 18, 2005
Messages
11,970
Location
U.K.
Format
35mm
IIRC, the test of whether a circular polarizer was required with a manual focus film camera turned on whether the camera used a beam splitter to divert a portion of the light for metering purposes.
I don't think that the AE-1 did.
That,'s right the AE -1 requires a linear polarizer, not a circular one.
 
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom