Control, by Anton Corbijn

[Michel Hardy-Vallée]

Just went to see the Montréal premiere of Control, about Joy Division and Ian Curtis, and it's AWESOME! Gorgeous cinematography, and really good acting. I've always been a Joy Division fan, and it was as close as I could imagine about being in a show.

The only thing is, I was perplexing myself throughout the movie: did they shoot on real B&W or did they desaturate color stock? The blacks had a slightly greenish tinge, which I'm tempted to equal with silver, but I can't be sure...

 

[Krockmitaine]

Thanks for the heads up.
Same here, always liked their music.
Unknown pleasures
So good
Now the trick is to get back to a civilised place asap and see the movie.

 

[Michael W]

The only thing is, I was perplexing myself throughout the movie: did they shoot on real B&W or did they desaturate color stock? The blacks had a slightly greenish tinge, which I'm tempted to equal with silver, but I can't be sure...

It was shot on Kodak colour neg Vision2 5217 200T
It went to a digital internegative where the desaturation was done & was then printed to colour film for release, which would explain the cast you saw.
http://www.cinematography.com/forum2004/index.php?showtopic=23014&hl=corbijn
I got this from a thread at cinematography.com
They tested B&W film but the grain was too heavy.

 

[Michel Hardy-Vallée]

Great, thanks for the thread link! The last B&W movie I saw was "Les amants réguliers", a French film about Mai 68, and it was definitely shot on real B&W (some of the stock was ORWO). The grain was very large, and it was rather mesmerizing to see the constant shifting clumps of graininess as the image moved.