Best film for Switzerland?

[Tori Nelson]

I have a friend who will be shooting in the mountains of Switzerland this month. She will be using 4x5 and would like some advice on which of these films she should by and what ASA would be best. I know nothing of either of these films but I think these are her only choices: EFKE PL or Rollei ATO.

Thanks for any advice.

 

[MattKing]

I apologize for this.

Something with a very neutral response.

 

[keithwms]

There is no best. There is what you have, to be used properly, and that's all.

 

[tomalophicon]

Definitely something with perforations

 

[dasBlute]

Try Kodak, Ilford or Fuji.

all kidding aside, use the film she is most familiar with.
Don't change horses just before entering new territory.

Any number of people will probably weigh in with their
favorites but - favorites, IMO, come from familiarity/experience
with the film.

 

[pbromaghin]

all kidding aside, use the film she is most familiar with.
Don't change horses just before entering new territory.

Excellent advice.

 

[cmo]

Tori, tell your friend to buy some very warm clothes instead and to take care in the mountains. Europe suffers from an extremely cold winter.

http://www.spiegel.de/fotostrecke/fotostrecke-78188.html

 

[markbarendt]

There is no best. There is what you have, to be used properly, and that's all.

+1

The only thing I'd add is that on any truly important shots, shoot 4 sheets.

Developed 1 at a time, that allows for changes in development if needed and to recover from film defects, bad luck, and human error if needed.

 

[Tori Nelson]

@ Matt, had to finish my coffee before I got that one - HAHAHAHA (delayed, but heartfelt response)
@ Keith, dasBlute, pbromaghin, & Mark - this is her first outing with 4x5 except for 4 sheets of HP5 she shot while visiting me in October. She has never processed any or had a chance to do any testing with different films to find what she likes best. She has an extremely limited budget to work with.
@ cmo, my friend lives in Moscow, LOL, so I think she might be set for cold weather.

I have tried to get Galja to introduce herself to the group but she is rather shy until she gets to know people. She is truly a gifted photographer with a raw talent and was being mentored by Per Volquartz (who introduced us). You can see her work here: Dead Link Removed The introduction was written as a tribute to her work, by Per.

 

[Thomas Bertilsson]

@ Matt, had to finish my coffee before I got that one - HAHAHAHA (delayed, but heartfelt response)
@ Keith, dasBlute, pbromaghin, & Mark - this is her first outing with 4x5 except for 4 sheets of HP5 she shot while visiting me in October. She has never processed any or had a chance to do any testing with different films to find what she likes best. She has an extremely limited budget to work with.
@ cmo, my friend lives in Moscow, LOL, so I think she might be set for cold weather.

I have tried to get Galja to introduce herself to the group but she is rather shy until she gets to know people. She is truly a gifted photographer with a raw talent and was being mentored by Per Volquartz (who introduced us). You can see her work here: Dead Link Removed The introduction was written as a tribute to her work, by Per.

Tori, I recognize both you and Galina from Facebook and other places, and it's good to see you here too!

I've admired her work for a long time; she really has a true gift. Regarding film it doesn't really matter what she uses. But to take a 4x5 camera after having shot only four sheets, on a trip to Europe, is a bit risky, to be honest. Sheet film gets easily fogged in airport X-ray machines, for example. If she's using a tripod, I'd be using a film with the lowest possible ISO rating, in order to avoid that problem.
If you can, please have her use the same film she uses for 35mm and other formats, as that would introduce as few variables as possible, and bring a roll film camera as back-up if she finds she gets stuck with the sheets.

Good luck!

 

[Tori Nelson]

Thank you Thomas, I will pass this on the Galja.