Just a little comparison between neg scan and print scan.
Not only is it a different quality, but it's also a different interpretation. I did not look at the print when I scanned the negative, and vice versa...
I posted this mainly because I find the comparison interesting, but there are some ulterior motives, and I'm glad we've reached a point of civil discussion.
1. I think that the final print is what matters too. I know I can express what I want in a print. I can hold it in my hands, and it's a tangible thing before me instead of a bunch of electrons.
2. I've been stuck without a darkroom for about a year and some odd months now, and it has sucked immensely to have to reside to film scanning and inkjet as output. The process is so sterile, dull, and boring, and I find it lacks a level of craftsmanship compared to digital imaging, and I missed that hands-on work tremendously. I was literally aching to go back into the dark after nearly a year of absence.
3. Grain and tonality. While one can adjust endless parameters of a picture digitally, my personal opinion is that it's easier to achieve what I want with darkroom work. Grain does not appear the same in a print as it does in a film scan, by far. Grain from film scan seems harsh and unfriendly, unless you have a really awesome scanner that resolves grain, while my darkroom prints appear much smoother, but also more acute at the same time. The tonality I get from a print also feels a lot more 'organic' and it's as though I'm able to pour how I feel about the subject matter onto the print by handling it physically with my own hands.
My preference is clear. I love to print in the darkroom, and I am so incredibly happy that I am able to do it again. Now I only have a bout two years worth of backlogged negatives to try to print up...
Looks great. I really don't shoot with the idea of producing a great negative, rather the negative I need for my print. I guess thats why I find my neg scans so embarassing and unsatisfying
Thank you all for your nice comments!
The joy of printing in the darkroom is something I cherish deeply, to be able to change the outcome by using my own skill, eyes, and hands. I feel very lucky to have that to look forward to.
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links. To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.
PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.