Well, I've been leaning towards the 45mm anyways for the smaller size and lower weight. I had not heard about this problem before. What causes the rattling?
Anecdotal, I realize but I had a large number of 45 and 55 P67 lenses go through my hands over the years. I never had a 45 that was truly impressive when pushed a bit (enlargement-wise). Almost all of the 55's were quite good. Two of the 45's were bought new, so I assume they hadn't been exposed to difficult circumstances.... Perhaps others have had different experiences but that was mine.
It is known there is a fairly wide variation in quality among the 45mm f4 lenses; it is just pot-luck whether you get one which is sharp across the range of turns noticably rather soft. I swear my 45mm is a gem!
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?