• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

Would we agree about Xtol... ?

1+1 or 1+3 for somewhat higher acutance (ie real edge sharpness excluding edge effects) than stock. Realistically you can't get much better acutance than XTOL or D-76 diluted 1+3.
Strange, I didn't get real grain edge sharpness with diluted Xtol, but I don't remember the two films I tried for that...
And I have never seen a print scan showing sharp grain...
Maybe we'll see that here soon.
 

Follow the instructions and you will not have particles as long as you have it heated to warm enough temperature and mix Solution A long enough.
 
Has someone got really sharp grain with Xtol?
Not scanned and sharpened digitally, but on darkroom prints...

Yes, all the time with stock XTOL and replenished XTOL, not with diluted XTOL.
 
Follow the instructions and you will not have particles as long as you have it heated to warm enough temperature and mix Solution A long enough.
I think you are mixing two different cases...
Common floaties or wrong mixing/temperature procedures are a common thing, but the particles from bad Xtol are different: they're bigger, and they don't get dissolved... They go to the bottom and stay: my bad Xtol is yet inside my glass bottles, some months ago, and those bigger, denser particles went to the bottom, where they are today, and they were not dissolved no matter the temperature or time.
The problem may have been manufacturing, and not packaging.