Which level of yellow filters for B&W?

Craig

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 8, 2004
Messages
2,405
Location
Calgary
Format
Multi Format
Thanks! I've hiked into Boom Lake before, but that was a long time ago.
 

Alex Benjamin

Subscriber
Joined
Aug 8, 2018
Messages
2,795
Location
Montreal
Format
Multi Format

Great advice. I knew I had read something similar once. Took me a while to find it, but I finally did. From Ansel Adams' Examples: The Making of 40 Photographs. In the comment on his "Sand Dunes, Sunrise" (1948), he writes:

"Edward [Weston's] first visit to Death Vally resulted in a number of failures. He used a strong yellow filter, thinking that such would separate earth and sky. He did not realize that yellow and reddish earth photographed with a yellow filter (like the Wratten No. 8, K2) will be overexposed if the normal filter factor is used, because filters pass their own color freely. He discovered that using the filter with no filter factor cause the earth to retain its inherent values, but the blue sky and the bluish shadows were definitely lowered in value. I thanked Edward for this information; on my first trip to Death Valley I followed his suggestions with considerable success."

Examples: The Making of 40 Photographs is a good book to learn about the effects of using different filters. Adams used filters in many more photographs than I thought, and he explains really well his different choices—as well as the different mistakes he made with them.
 

Rob Skeoch

Advertiser
Advertiser
Joined
Apr 25, 2005
Messages
1,346
Location
Grand Valley, Ontario
Format
35mm RF
B+W uses a different coding for their filters.
A 022 looks yellow, and sucks up one stop of light.... it's not enough unless you're at elevation where the effect is greater.
A 040 looks orange, and sucks up two stops... this is my go-to filter for black and white and all you really need.
A 090 looks red, and is too much.... leaving the shadows hollow since they tend to be lit by the blue sky light, which has a blue cast, and is greatly affected. It's three stops. At elevation, it's really too much.
A 092 is very dark red, and for shooting IR film. You can't focus with the filter in place unless you're using a rangefinder camera or maybe a twin lens.
 

gone

Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2009
Messages
5,504
Location
gone
Format
Medium Format
It probably depends on what effect you want. For me, a K2 gave me somewhat minimal loss of light combined with darker, more contrasty skies and clouds. I just keep a K2 screwed onto any lens I own. If you were in lower light levels, the lighter Yellow filter might be better for focusing.

Unlike Rob, I never got on w/ an orange filter, especially if my subject was Black. It made my wife's skin color look very different than she actually looked like in person.
 
Last edited:

GregY

Member
Joined
Apr 12, 2005
Messages
3,766
Location
Alberta
Format
Large Format

I don't use filters for portraiture, but i use both yellow (1 stop) and orange (2 stop) all the time in the mountains.....& as Drew pointed out.... i've got some greens for visits in the SW USA.
 

Pieter12

Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2017
Messages
7,872
Location
Magrathean's computer
Format
Super8
Filters for portraiture can be tricky. Depends on the skin tone and the effect you're after. No filter is usually the best route. Different filters that affect red can exacerbate blotchiness or turn skin ashen or pitch black. I believe Ansel Adams recommended a green filter for male Caucasian subjects, making them look more "rugged."
 

Sirius Glass

Subscriber
Joined
Jan 18, 2007
Messages
50,623
Location
Southern California
Format
Multi Format

Yes, that is why I bought the Green and Yellow Green filters.
 
OP
OP

jay moussy

Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2019
Messages
1,315
Location
Eastern MA, USA
Format
Hybrid
I am hand-metering with older SLRs.
Rule of thumb to compensate for filter light absorption?
 

macfred

Subscriber
Joined
Nov 6, 2014
Messages
3,839
Location
Germany
Format
Multi Format
I usually use a yellow-green filter (+1) when taking photographs outside - dark yellow (+2) or even medium orange (+2.5) for darkening skies and for better clouds.

Yellow-green with blue skies and a red-head girl (400TX):

Medium-orange, blue skies and brick (TMY 400):
 

DREW WILEY

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2011
Messages
14,580
Format
8x10 Format
Rob - glad you pointed out the differences in brand numbering. I once ordered a 22 B&W filter assuming it meant the same thing as a deep orange Heliopan 22, but it didn't, and was pale orange instead. B&W had a completely different number for what I actually wanted, which I don't think they even make anymore.
 

JPD

Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2007
Messages
2,163
Location
Sweden
Format
Medium Format
A deep yellow filter like #15 will cut through some haze for sharper and contrastier details in the distance. Not as much as an orange filter, but with less risk of the results looking too dramatic.
 
OP
OP

jay moussy

Member
Joined
Jun 10, 2019
Messages
1,315
Location
Eastern MA, USA
Format
Hybrid
Well, a friendly neighbor gave me an 85A orange-y filter... worth experimenting, not expecting much due to low density?
Some readings say it will have zero B&W effect (except maybe flash use?), others liken it to a weak yellow.
 

Pieter12

Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2017
Messages
7,872
Location
Magrathean's computer
Format
Super8
I am hand-metering with older SLRs.
Rule of thumb to compensate for filter light absorption?
You really should figure out you own filter factor combined with each type of film you use. Start with the stated factor (sometimes expressed in stops, sometimes as filter factors, which are not stops) and the ISO you have determined for each film. Set up a tripod and shoot the same scene, bracketing by 1/2-1/3 stop over and under. Then examine the results and use the factor that gives you the effect you expect and want for that filter. Easiest done with 35mm, lots of exposures per roll. This method is also recommended with TTL metering, as some photocells react differently to different wavelengths of light.
 
Last edited:

Nicholas Lindan

Advertiser
Advertiser
Joined
Sep 2, 2006
Messages
4,291
Location
Cleveland, Ohio
Format
Multi Format
Well, a friendly neighbor gave me an 85A orange-y filter.

That's not going to do much of anything unless you want to shoot tungsten balanced Kodachrome outdoors.

With the price of filters on ebay you can afford to buy a selection of colors and try for yourself. Great way to waste a lovely afternoon.

IMO, Filters are the most over-hyped photographic accessory. Any old brand of filter will give identical results (any filter that hasn't been run over by a truck first). Hmm, 'Diana' style filters might catch on - need to buy a truck first.
 

DREW WILEY

Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2011
Messages
14,580
Format
8x10 Format
An 85A will act like any hypothetical contrast amberish filter of the same hue. It will not be inert with b&w film, but have some effect at least But that probably won't be enough for typical b&w expectations like a deeper orange might be. And there won't be any published filter factor recommendations for pan film.
 

CMoore

Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2015
Messages
6,235
Location
USA CA
Format
35mm

Street Photography is pretty much all i do.
My experience is Definitely in line with what you say above.
There are always exceptions, but generally speaking you hit the nail on the right part.
 

Philippe-Georges

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 11, 2005
Messages
2,680
Location
Flanders Fields
Format
Medium Format
Even with brass filter rings, a filter wrench (or a set of them) is handy to keep in your bag. Really makes removing a stuck filter much easier.

Just to say: that's why Hasselblad uses the hood, and/or a thick toothed retaining ring (#50350), to mount the (series VIII-) filters, and bajonet mounts for smaler diameters...
 

Philippe-Georges

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 11, 2005
Messages
2,680
Location
Flanders Fields
Format
Medium Format
This is what a (dark-) red filter does in the city, sidewalk cobbles and the building's stones on the right are of bluestone, the roofs in slate.
Film exposed at 1600ASA (handheld).

And this is what an orange filter does in the same city but on an other day.
Film exposed at box speed (handheld).


Hasselblad SWC on Tri-X in E-76 1+1 and wet scanned on Epson 750.
 
Last edited:

ic-racer

Member
Joined
Feb 25, 2007
Messages
16,664
Location
USA
Format
Multi Format
Just kidding! No filter.

Just to make the point, that without the comparison print with no sky burn, who can tell anything about the filter's effect.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…