Just thought i'd chime in with my experience. I've been shooting digital(photography actually) for a year but after a year or so of it i've found that not only image output but the whole philosophy of digital 'snaps' to be an already unexciting prospect. Despite it's ease of use, yes sometimes high quality pictures etc.
The concept of time is ever present on my mind ever more frequently when I take pictures, cameras are a time machine and that's their magic. Shutterspeed, moments etc. And I just find something about the process of film gets me more in touch with the actual workings and time of photography. The (now cheap) metal bodies, hand on a manual focus ring/aperture, the winding of film. It's a process and it gets me focussed on what i'm doing as a process.
And now as I move forward to soon start developing my own film I get to be more in touch with that process.
Yes digital is great. I use it for my high magnification 1-5X+ insect photos.
But there's nothing (for me as I haven't experience 4x5 other than polaroid instant on a calumet 4x5 studio camera I found in the
garbage) like shooting 120 color/black and white film. Better image quality (highlights - shooting into the sun, long exposures etc) and just in general a better feel.
I have already given away some cheap 35mm cameras (a couple Olympus Trip 35s) to friends to enjoy but I do already get the 'is that film!' comments.
I have to say though being a music lover that I never got onto the whole vinyl over CD thing although many of my friends have. After a few plays of vinyl any quality it'd have over CD is mute point. BUT I don't mind vinyl on certain recordings (especially pre 60s) that were made on completely analogue equipment (be-bop, blues etc) where it makes sense.
To make an analogy between the two I would say that music is made for different rooms (Talking Heads lead singer has a discussion on this on TEDtalks and i've long thought about it), for example Be-Bop was made in small jazz clubs and Led Zeppelin rock arenas. It doesn't make sense to see Led Zeppelin at some tiny folk bar. Vinyl for some artists, digital for others. I would make the same argument about digital/film/film formats.
But one thing is for sure is that film needs a revival, it almost needs a Ghost World (Steve Buscemi is in it and weird collector of old jazz records) where today's generation can reconnect with it in my opinion. Be it a movie, an exciting product release (please polaroid?) or we can just start with our own word of mouth. And I think that passing on film knowledge, excitement and so on is really important. Since i'm a bit of an alternative person i'm already here and interested and doing it on my own but others need a bit of a helping hand
.
-Brendon