What is consider a photograph?

Frank Dean,  Blacksmith

A
Frank Dean, Blacksmith

  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
Woman wearing shades.

Woman wearing shades.

  • 0
  • 0
  • 12
Curved Wall

A
Curved Wall

  • 4
  • 0
  • 63
Crossing beams

A
Crossing beams

  • 9
  • 1
  • 88
Shadow 2

A
Shadow 2

  • 4
  • 0
  • 63

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
198,837
Messages
2,781,643
Members
99,723
Latest member
bookchair
Recent bookmarks
0

Saganich

Subscriber
Joined
Nov 21, 2004
Messages
1,274
Location
Brooklyn
Format
35mm RF
She should give the $$ to Grandma. I suppose that it's a developed piece of film so would technically qualify as a photograph.
 

ntenny

Subscriber
Joined
Mar 5, 2008
Messages
2,477
Location
Portland, OR, USA
Format
Multi Format
I think if you acknowledge Man Ray's "rayographs" as photography, you have to acknowledge this piece too.

Whether it's *good* photography, or good art, is a whole separate and obviously subjective question. Personally I fail to see the point.

-NT
 

Sirius Glass

Subscriber
Joined
Jan 18, 2007
Messages
50,364
Location
Southern California
Format
Multi Format
Not a photograph.
 
OP
OP
Mainecoonmaniac
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
6,297
Format
Multi Format
Photo means light. Graph means to write. No light was used so maybe it isn't technically a photograph?
 

Craig75

Member
Joined
May 9, 2016
Messages
1,234
Location
Uk
Format
35mm
If people didnt do things like this we would be sentenced to an eternal purgatory of pictures of road signs and trees.
 

dpurdy

Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2006
Messages
2,673
Location
Portland OR
Format
8x10 Format
I actually like it, reminds me of Cy Twombly one of my favorite painters. I am sure he was criticized heavily for his work and questioned whether it was painting or not. I can't bring myself to be interested in the question of whether it is a photograph or not.
 

miha

Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2007
Messages
2,962
Location
Slovenia
Format
Multi Format
Photo means light. Graph means to write. No light was used so maybe it isn't technically a photograph?
How come no light was used? Of course this is a photograph or at least the film is, providing the print was done via RA4 and not inkjet, the end product also qulifies as s photograph.
 

Bob Carnie

Subscriber
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
7,735
Location
toronto
Format
Med. Format RF
If people didnt do things like this we would be sentenced to an eternal purgatory of pictures of road signs and trees.
rocks, waterfalls, mountain scenes and the dreaded group nude photo shoot.
 

OptiKen

Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2013
Messages
1,055
Location
Orange County
Format
Medium Format
This is my comment on it:

To me, this is notable ONLY with the accompanying artist's statement. I believe that a photograph (sketch or painting for that matter) should be able to stand alone. Sort of like if you have to explain a joke, it isn't funny. The photograph should be able to convey mood and emotion. This only conveys that to the photographer. Without her statement, it conveys none of that. Somehow, this reminds me of the story about THE EMPEROR'S NEW CLOTHES.
Give the money back
 

MattKing

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
52,939
Location
Delta, BC Canada
Format
Medium Format
I can understand a part of the controversy - it may not fit within the "Conditions of Entry" definitions:

"2) ENTRY ELIGIBILITY: Entry must be:
· A new portrait completed since 1 April 2015, owned and created by the artist; not
previously exhibited (including online but excluding the entrant’s personal webpage or
social media platform), shown in competitions or awarded a prize;
· Photographic, archivally sound, still and two-dimensional;
· Within the size limits and able to be hung on or pinned to Gallery walls.
The Judge will be looking for excellence in photographic technique, creativity and originality
to the standards prescribed by the Director, Tweed Regional Gallery."

But IMHO, it is sufficiently interesting to be worthy of display.
 

moose10101

Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
846
Location
Maryland, US
Format
Medium Format
She should give the $$ to Grandma. I suppose that it's a developed piece of film so would technically qualify as a photograph.

Yes, she should, since Grandma actually created the "image". Processing the film and printing it doesn't make you the photographer (or whatever "-ographer" applies here).
 

blockend

Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2010
Messages
5,049
Location
northern eng
Format
35mm
I actually like it, reminds me of Cy Twombly one of my favorite painters. I am sure he was criticized heavily for his work and questioned whether it was painting or not. I can't bring myself to be interested in the question of whether it is a photograph or not.
I also like the image very much. Whether it's a photograph or not depends if the interventions are conditional on the the light sensitive materials. The use of stretched canvas does not make an artwork a painting, not does the immersion of an unexposed film in pre-wash make it a photographic negative. I would describe the interventions of Stephen Gill as photographs, but this work is trickier. If a print was made from the negative or slide it would seem to be a photograph of something.
 

bsdunek

Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
1,611
Location
Michigan
Format
Multi Format
I think if you acknowledge Man Ray's "rayographs" as photography, you have to acknowledge this piece too.

Whether it's *good* photography, or good art, is a whole separate and obviously subjective question. Personally I fail to see the point.

-NT
I agree. It is like a "rayograph" or a photogram or a chemigram, etc. I just look at the end result, which in this case, I like.
 

bsdunek

Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
1,611
Location
Michigan
Format
Multi Format
I think if you acknowledge Man Ray's "rayographs" as photography, you have to acknowledge this piece too.

Whether it's *good* photography, or good art, is a whole separate and obviously subjective question. Personally I fail to see the point.

-NT
I agree. It is like a "rayograph" or a photogram or a chemigram, etc. I just look at the end result, which in this case, I like.
 

OptiKen

Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2013
Messages
1,055
Location
Orange County
Format
Medium Format
"There is no accounting for taste"
 

Cholentpot

Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2015
Messages
6,743
Format
35mm
No effort expended mental or physical. It's an insult to creativity.
 

Theo Sulphate

Member
Joined
Jul 3, 2014
Messages
6,489
Location
Gig Harbor
Format
Multi Format
Ah, well - it is what it is. However, I'd bet that if she photographed the paper containing her grandmother's pen-test scratchings, it would've looked better and been more appealing.

There is a story, true or not, of an artist who was so angry about his works not selling that he threw something at one of his finished works (or he ripped it or cut it) and that one became his most valuable work simply because it expressed emotion so well.
 

pentaxuser

Member
Joined
May 9, 2005
Messages
19,956
Location
Daventry, No
Format
35mm
I could not believe what I was reading. It has to be a joke surely. I was able to laugh because none of the prize money came out of my bank account. :D

Give me a road sign any day

pentaxuser
 

eddie

Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2005
Messages
3,258
Location
Northern Vir
Format
Multi Format
I've often been told my photographs aren't really photographs, so I have empathy for the artist. I also find it an interesting image, ( I'd like to see it in person) most likely worthy of the prize. Personally, I'm a fan of people who push the envelope.
 
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom