I assume it is still a topic, in part, because that solution by itself doesn't work perfectly for everyone every time. The water supply and darkroom conditions are different everywhere. I imagine not all 'deionised water' is equal either.
true, it's easy to assume that what works for one person also would work for another person, which is not always the case.
still, I find it difficult to imagine that this wouldn't work everywhere.
we have very hard water here (20 °dH) and the process involved is very straight forward. I use cheap deionized water from the drug store/supermarket meant for household purposes (ironing).