• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

Those who take and those who make

Hard to get away with "Just snapping pictures" when using a classy-looking 100+ year old 5x7. They won't believe you. There is a point where feigned modesty starts to sound a bit pretentious.

As the size of the film increases so does the resistance to take snapshots. By 5"x7" my taking snapshots is long dead and buried.
 

Two countries separated by common language.

From: https://english.stackexchange.com/q...rase-two-nations-divided-by-a-common-language

What is the origin of the phrase "two nations divided by a common language"?


What is the origin of the phrase "two nations divided by a common language"?
I have seen it attributed to Oscar Wilde, George Bernard Shaw and even Winston Churchill.
The most likely looking source I found said:
 

Depends on what I am doing.

If am involved with holidays, family events, or looking at the squirrel on my front porch, I am shooting snapshots. That is to say, I am casually capturing what's going on and thus I am just taking what is there. This is a recording process.

Conversely, the attempt to create art is a consciously constructive process that always involves an attempt to interpret what we see. We thus make art out of the things we see and can imagine seeing - or at least we attempt to.

While it is possible to produce an aesthetically pleasing snapshot, unless it was somehow constructed, I'd argue it's never art. But what do I know ...
 

Do you feel the same way about other artisans when they say things like, "I made that sculpture" or "Larry made that beautiful wood turning"?
 
Does anyone actually say to their family, "I'm going out to build (make) some pictures?

I do sometimes say to my wife that I'm going out to make some photos.
To which she usually responds with something about how my "futzing" around with my cameras is best done when she is elsewhere.
Followed by something like "just take something, so we can go!"
 
If someone sees you with a large format camera, they generally don't think you're taking snapshots. They think you're an idiot wasting your time with a piece of junk. Or, just as likely, that you're trying to level your transit.
 

If I ever said "I'm going to check out the light." my family would think I was really weird, probably having some sort of religious experience, and lock me up. How about I:m going out to "record" some pictures? I don;t think that word has been mentioned. We do record whether its with film or a sensor/memory card. The one photographer I know who builds his pictures is Creydson.
 

You meet some pretty girls using film cameras.
 
Yeah..... this thread hearkens back to posts about "Being An Artist"
And again, i am not just picking on photography. Most hobbies suffer similar scenarios
Some people, when asked, just cannot stop at......... carpenter, painter, guitar player, photographer, sculptor, etc etc etc.
They have to claim to be an "Artist" ............ not unlike people with a PhD, in one field or another, calling themselves a doctor
 
... How about I:m going out to "record" some pictures? ...

That would be questionable use of words. To record a record? (A picture is a type of recording.) Quite understandable if one is photographing in a gallery where there are pictures to record. But I can easily understand if someone said, "I am going out to record my experiences today." Might be with a camera or a journal, or both.

But light is my primary subject, so I get carried away with it..
 
not unlike people with a PhD, in one field or another, calling themselves a doctor

PhD graduates are, quite literally, "doctors". Philosophiae Doctor is what they are. Or DPhil, Doctor of Philosophy, as they are known when they obtain the title from the most prestigious university in the world, University of Oxford, UK.

The ones you are thinking about, who later appropriated the "doctor" title, are "physicians".
 
To record a record?

The second word is a verb. The forth word is a noun.

How about I:m going out to "record" some pictures? I don;t think that word has been mentioned.

It's been mentioned several times.

As for Gregory Crewdson, those photos involve a massive amount of preparation and quite a few people, more similar to movie production than to studio photography (which can also be elaborate and involve many people). He tends to expose a number of near-identical sheets of film that all get scanned and combined into the finished photo on a computer (that work is also executed by someone else - he directs it). He "makes" his photos, to use the terminology Clive introduced this thread with, because of the final manipulation of that image.

If he'd set up the scene, exposed one negative, and made a print from that -- that would be "taking" a photo (as Clive put it).

What he built was the scene.
 
Im taking a break from the keyboard today to document the interactions of light with a variety of subjects including, but not limited to, reflections and shadows using chemical-based recording media.

I shall not take or make or fake, nor shall I shake. And God help me if I even think of shooting anyone or anything.
 

Don't capture either. It's not nice.
 

Not quite. The term "Doctor" originally meant "teacher" and was applied to many fields, among them medicine. So no medical appropriation can be claimed. See:


 
The term "Doctor" originally meant "teacher" and was applied to many fields, among them medicine.

The divide between academic fields wasn't particularly strict in the Renaissance.
On the PhD thing - it's actually amusing to read how e.g. the PhD defense of Felix Platter shows parallels with customs still in use today (see the book by Emmanual Le Roy Ladurie on the Platter family). Platter, coincidentally, was a doctor in medicine, and he obtained a PhD. So he was a doctor, doctor, I guess. Or maybe a doctor, squared, even.
 

Very cool historical reference, thanks for that.

I never finished my Ph.D. I thus describe myself as a college drop out.
 
I thought that was "wake & bake"?

No shake & bake refers to earthquakes & fires and a product for coating food with bread crumbs product called "Shake & Bake".