The necessity of secondary fixer ingredients

drp

Member
Joined
Mar 15, 2008
Messages
28
Format
Multi Format
Hi,

I've been making Bill Troop's TF-2 and TF-3 fixers which consist of using sodium thiosulfate and ammonium thiosulfate, respectively, as the main fixer ingredient. The secondary ingredients to both include sodium sulfite and sodium metaborate. If I use these fixers one shot and I'm not concerned with turning them alkaline with the secondary ingredients or storing a stock solution, wouldn't I more or less get the same fixing effect?

Thanks!
 

Anon Ymous

Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2008
Messages
3,663
Location
Greece
Format
35mm
Yes, you would. You can use straight sodium/ammonium thiosulfate if you use it one shot.
 

reddesert

Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2019
Messages
2,438
Location
SAZ
Format
Hybrid
The Darkroom Cookbook recommends against using a "plain hypo" (sodium thiosulfate only) fixer as the primary fixer for several reasons, including poor keeping, may produce stains, less effective. I expect these would also apply to a plain ammonium thiosulfate solution. The purpose of the other ingredients are (AFAIK) that sodium sulfite dissolves some silver halides and preserves the ionic content of the fixer, and that sodium metaborate makes it alkaline, which aids in keeping the thiosulfate ion in solution and I think promotes the fixing reaction. One would have to look at a photo chemistry book to get more details.
 

Doremus Scudder

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2002
Messages
3,598
Location
Eugene, Oregon
Format
4x5 Format
Sodium sulfite is an oxygen scavenging preservative to keep the thiosulfates from oxidizing. That can fairly quickly without the sulfite (think long printing session).

The metaborate is there to make the fixer more alkaline, which helps both films and papers to fix a bit faster and, more importantly, wash faster.

The real reason to use the "secondary" ingredients is for economy. It's pretty wasteful to mix up a single-ingredient fixer at a dilution that allows full fixing (ionic content is important) in a reasonable time, then use it once and toss it after it has only reached a tenth (or less) of its capacity. I question why you would want to do that.

Best,

Doremus
 

Randy Stewart

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2006
Messages
278
Format
Medium Format

"Fixing" is the process of dissolving undeveloped silver halides in the emulsion, so yes, the end-result of using either primary fixer ingredient is the same. The difference is the speed of the chemical process. Sodium thiosulfate is your basic, traditional fixer, I.e. "Kodak Fixer". Ammonium thiosulfate is the primary fixing agent in "rapid fixers", commonly doing the job in half or a third of the time of a traditional fixer. Sodium thiosulfate used to be cheap as dirt. Ammonium thiosulfate has always been much more expensive.
 

MattKing

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
53,326
Location
Delta, BC Canada
Format
Medium Format
Randy Stewart said:
Sodium thiosulfate is your basic, traditional fixer, I.e. "Kodak Fixer"
Click to expand...

For clarity, this is correct for the powder version.
The more recently found liquid "Kodak Fixer" is actually very similar to ammonium thiosulfate based Kodak Rapid Fixer, with hardener already added.
 

MattKing

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
53,326
Location
Delta, BC Canada
Format
Medium Format
Tim Stapp said:
Might this be due to the new producer of Kodak Chemicals, Photo Solutions?
Click to expand...

If this is a response to my post, the liquid Kodak Fixer is very similar to Polymax Fixer, which I understand to have been available in non-USA/Canada markets for some time.
 

xkaes

Subscriber
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
4,798
Location
Colorado
Format
Multi Format
Randy Stewart said:
Sodium thiosulfate used to be cheap as dirt.
Click to expand...

It still is -- so says my wallet. And so is ammonium chloride -- to speed things up.

OK, dirt can be expensive -- especially close to downtown Las Vegas.
 

Rudeofus

Member
Joined
Aug 13, 2009
Messages
5,082
Location
EU
Format
Medium Format
xkaes said:
It still is -- so says my wallet. And so is ammonium chloride -- to speed things up.

OK, dirt can be expensive -- especially close to downtown Las Vegas.
Click to expand...

If a roll of cheap B&W film costs more than 10x the amount you pay for the fixer to process it, then cost savings become moot at some point. I've been using a Sodium Thiosulfate plus Ammonium Chloride fixer to fix prints for years, even posted a working recipe here in the articles section.

The very cheap availability of C-41 fixer concentrates and their threefold capacity over Sodium Thiosulfate bases fixers (with or without Ammonium Chloride) made me switch to rapid fixers for good. I'd use that neutral quick fixer formula of mine only if pricing or availability of rapid fixers change substantially.
 

xkaes

Subscriber
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
4,798
Location
Colorado
Format
Multi Format
We obvious buy at different places. RAPID fixer DIES too fast -- for the price. That makes it much more expensive. Sodium thiosulfate is as close to free -- around here -- at swimming pool supply shops.

Good luck with however you do it. That might not be the best bet for everyone. It isn't for me.
 

john_s

Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2002
Messages
2,153
Location
Melbourne, A
Format
Medium Format
xkaes said:
We obvious buy at different places. RAPID fixer DIES too fast -- for the price. That makes it much more expensive. Sodium thiosulfate is as close to free -- around here -- at swimming pool supply shops.
Click to expand...

Rapid fixer might be dying fast because of its low pH. That's an advantage of C-41 fixer because its pH is higher, just a shade under neutral. Unfortunately where I live C-41 fixer is harder to source at anything like its old price advantage.
 

xkaes

Subscriber
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
4,798
Location
Colorado
Format
Multi Format
Sorry to hear you are in between a rock and a hard place. I would be too if sodium thiosulfate wasn't so cheap -- around here.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…