I think that at times it's easy to believe that someone who likes what we like is imbued with some special insight or sophistication lacking in others who just "don't get it". I have a hard time understanding how someone could prefer vanilla ice cream to chocolate, but I respect their preference and don't offer them chocolate ice cream.
I believe that jdef has properly clarified my view with the above quote. No disrespect intended to anybody that participates on this or any other form, but we are all biased in one way or another.
My simple point is that for my photographs ....these need to satisfy my desires and asthetic <sp> objectives to be successful in my eyes. If others like what I do I am pleased but do not require that be so. I thought this thread was started to discuss an appropriate way to offer a viewpoint on somebody elses work and not a discussion on who "qualifies" as a professional critic.
Perhaps some folks should step back and consider other aspects of their life. How do you feel when somebody tries to tell you which way to "vote". Or perhaps somebody has gone to great lengths to tell you which vehicle to buy that would be best for you. Is this "THAT" much different that trying to claim that your eyesight, photographic skills and evaluation is so much above anybody else that can see?
For myself, my selection and tastes in cars, women, and photography (to name a few) please me in the way I want. I do not need or require anybody to re-educate me into believing that their assessment is superior to mine. My brain works just fine in this fashion. I am quite able to learn and re-evaluate things and evolve in an ongoing basis as I proceed throughout this life.
As the original post suggests "Why is it so important that you tell me how to view the photographic world according to you?"
I ask "Why can you not just walk a mile in my shoes and accept that I am both capable and happy in making my own evaluations without your insistent views to the contrary?"
"Why can you not accept that others are not ignorant, unskilled or without the ability to view and evaluate just because they do not aggressively speak out at every opportunity?"
Kind Regards,