Hi Paul, In some ways I'm the wrong person to ask, because I started with
Greenlaw's process and I like it so much that making good calotypes with that process is still my main interest. So I haven't tried very many others. Also, I started with Canson marker paper, and it didn't work well. So I tried Canson vidalon vellum and it did work very well, but it is difficult to work with. I stuck with it and learned how to deal with the curl and the shrinking and the wrinkles. If you could find a paper that's easier to handle than vidalon, and still works well, then this process is about as simple as any of them.
I used those instructions linked above. It's not terribly complicated:
- iodize the paper ( soak in potassium iodide, with a little acetic acid and optionally some potassium bromide ), dry
- sensitize the paper ( float or immerse the paper in silver nitrate solution with a little acetic acid ), wash in water, dry
- make the exposure in the next 12 hours or so
- develop in gallic acid + a few drops of silver nitrate, wash
- fix in hypo, wash
Of course all the steps have details that are part of the craft that you learn as you go. Especially you start to learn what a calotype that prints well looks like, and what to look for when developing. Also, Alan Greene's book "Primitive Photography" is good, even if you don't end up using the process he describes, it's worth reading because he goes though all the steps.