Square Wave Light Source or Transformer lens

Joined
Oct 29, 2006
Messages
4,829
Location
İstanbul
Format
35mm
I started to read CTEIN book and at first page , there was an idea. He wrote square wave light is sharper.
Is there a square wave light source or a lens transforms the curvey psf to square.
This is possible with Radar.

Best ,

Umut
Istanbul
 

rco3

Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2009
Messages
22
Location
Merritt Isla
Format
Medium Format
Are you referring to a mention in "Post Exposure" by Ctein? If so, could you direct me to where in the book this discussion takes place? I'm having a bit of trouble understanding this on a theoretical basis.
 

Steven K

Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2011
Messages
16
Location
New York, NY
Format
Multi Format
If you're referring to Ctein's _Post Exposure_, he is not writing about square wave 'light'. It's a discussion of acutance as one of the factors of perceived sharpness in a print. He's talking about sharp edges as opposed to blurry edges here (page 3 of my PDF copy of Post Exposure, 2nd Edition):


He's talking about the density of ink on paper if you graph it, like a densitometer trace. Cross a sharp edge, and it looks like a square wave function. Cross a blurry edge and the density rises gradually, and could resemble a sine wave. "Wave" in this context, refers to functions he used in his mathematical derivation, not anything physical that relates to a lens, light source, or enlarger.

cheers,

Steven
 
OP
OP
Joined
Oct 29, 2006
Messages
4,829
Location
İstanbul
Format
35mm
rco3 and Steven K ,

I think square wave tema is the subject of wave optics and its a large ocean . I think there must be a breadboard laser or microchip fabrication physical application. May be lens point spread function can be calibrated in to square wave.
I will wait more answers.

Thank you ,

Umut
 

Monito

Member
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
335
Location
Nova Scotia,
Format
Multi Format
I started to read CTEIN book and at first page , there was an idea. He wrote square wave light is sharper.
Is there a square wave light source or a lens transforms the curvey psf to square.
This is possible with Radar.

Wrong.

1) It's on page 3.

2) ctein actually wrote: I’ll spare you the math, which is beyond the
scope of this book (it involves Fourier transforms,
if you want to work it out for yourself ). The difference
between a sharp edge and a fuzzy one (a
square wave and a sine wave) corresponds to a
difference in spatial detail three times finer than
the line spacing.


3) There is no mention of square wave light.

4) What is discussed is square wave edges in images. That means where the image (negative) presents an abrupt sudden change from light to dark or the reverse.

5) Since light is simply electromagnetic radiation, square waveform electromagnetic radiation would be possible, but it would not look like light, since only the fundamental frequency would be visible. The rest of the harmonics needed to actually produce a square wave would be up in the ultraviolet and x-ray radiation regions.

6) Light is a narrow band of wavelengths, basically from 400 nanometers (nm) to 700 nm. You need to comprehend this fundamental fact of great importance to understanding photography.

7) A study of the waveform harmonic characteristics of square waveforms shows that they are composed of a harmonic series of the odd integer harmonics. That means frequencies 3, 5, 7, ... times the fundamental frequency. When this is combined with point (6) above you have the reason for point (5).
 

E76

Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2008
Messages
401
Location
Baltimore, MD
Format
Medium Format
You don't want a square, or rect, for your PSF. Ideally you'd want a dirac delta. Think about what would happen if you imaged a really thin line using your lens with a rect for a PSF. Would you still get that really thin line or would that line spread out to be the width of that rect?
 
OP
OP
Joined
Oct 29, 2006
Messages
4,829
Location
İstanbul
Format
35mm
Let me ask an question ,

Lets imagine contact printing with UV for PT PD. What would be the sharpness difference between square wave illumination and the curvey.
 

Monito

Member
Joined
May 16, 2011
Messages
335
Location
Nova Scotia,
Format
Multi Format
Let me ask an question ,

Lets imagine contact printing with UV for PT PD. What would be the sharpness difference between square wave illumination and the curvey.

Go back and study light. You won't get square wave illumination for the reasons explained above. Square wave electromagnetic illumination with a fundamental frequency in the visible spectrum would have radiative frequencies (in the harmonics) that are injurious to life and your eyesight. Don't attempt it. Until you understand that point you are wasting your time and the time of others kind enough to respond to you.

By the way, what do you mean by "PT PD"? Post-traumatic photographic disorder?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

trexx

Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2004
Messages
291
Location
Tucson
Format
4x5 Format
Let me ask an question ,

Lets imagine contact printing with UV for PT PD. What would be the sharpness difference between square wave illumination and the curvey.

None, if the light source was other wise the same. What may impact would be a diffused verses a colaminar, condenser, light source.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…