I already posted a link to S. I. Howard Glass, Co., (
http://www.howardglass.com/) but with the description of the application, their products looks fully appropriate. I don't think you need optical flatness, meaning measured in wavelengths of light. Certainly the scanner manufacturers aren't using that grade of glass.
Their soda lime glass is available in thickness of 0.40, 0.55, 0.70, 0.90, 1.1, 1.2, 1.6 mm, all the way up to 19 mm. Typical prices for thicknesses around 1 mm are $1.15 per square foot. Sizes are various, such as 20 x 20 inches. I think they cut to the size that you want.
Perhaps their B270 super white crown glass is better. They emphasize its optical clearness. It costs a lot more.