Thanks, both. I'm thinking it's just old. I spent $12 on it, so I'm not too worried. The tonality is really nice (especially the shadows), but the grade 4 looks like a grade 3 compared to my VC stuff (although I am using off-brand mg filters on the VC paper, so that may be the problem).
Any thoughts on this paper compared to Emaks? Most noticeable differences? Emaks is next on my list.
I may become a graded paper convert. There's just something about these that looks better than my VC stuff.