Which substrate do you use?
So far I've found the generic screen printing film I've been using fairly tough, although anything will scratch if I'm being too clumsy with it.
Perhaps just store them in transparent sleeves and only take out to print?
I suppose you could spray some kind of fixative onto them, but I've never tried it. I consider digital negatives more of a disposable, to be honest.
It's an unnamed product (they didn't want to share the manufacturers name for some reason) from thescreenprintstore.ca:
Canada's source for everything you need to screen print and silk screen t-shirts.
www.thescreenprintstore.ca
This product cost me $59.95 Canadian ($44.98 US) for 100 sheets of 8.5x11.
Both Pictorico and Fixxons are hard to find in Canada, and expensive. Pictorico Premium OHP from B&H is $29.95 for 20 sheets of 8.5x11, so would cost me $149.75 US ($199.60 Canadian) for 100 sheets.
Egad.
I'm at the bottom of the learning curve, so didn't want to be too hindered by cost.
We have an Epson P600 and in ABW mode at the darkest setting there is absolutely no indication that the material is being overwhelmed.