Thank you !
I'd like to tell more about this documentary but my lack of language don't help to be precise.
You seem very interested in this political point.
I'm also surprised that you don't have the curiosity to inform yourself.
I am not very comfortable with your emphasis on this subject.
I suggest you read some neutral information, for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romani_people_in_France
Your pictures do tell the "story". I also see a lot of joy despite difficult circumstances. The other poster is right though, how can we know this is in France? You didn't include the obligatory baguette in every picture. Pictures telling a whole story is a myth. We always need background info.
How curious that now several people have made this point. You realize that the OP is from and in France? Would you demand the same from a photographer from your country, taking pictures in your country? Is it because he added the info that it's in France, so the pictures need to prove that extravagant claim?The only critique I could offer is regarding "France"... these wonderful photos could be of the Romany people anywhere.
How curious that now several people have made this point. You realize that the OP is from and in France? Would you demand the same from a photographer from your country, taking pictures in your country? Is it because he added the info that it's in France, so the pictures need to prove that extravagant claim?
Your pictures are top notch I think but need words to make their point.
Nothing is being “demanded” and there is no “extravagant claim” being made. A title is a title. The title describes a collection of very fine photographs. It’s a fine title. Without the title it might not be apparent that scenes of people in France were being documented. That’s all… don’t make more out of a very minor comment than is really intended.How curious that now several people have made this point. You realize that the OP is from and in France? Would you demand the same from a photographer from your country, taking pictures in your country? Is it because he added the info that it's in France, so the pictures need to prove that extravagant claim?
Nothing is being “demanded” and there is no “extravagant claim” being made. A title is a title. The title describes a collection of very fine photographs. It’s a fine title. Without the title it might not be apparent that scenes of people in France were being documented. That’s all… don’t make more out of a very minor comment than is really intended.
Laurent, I feel like I owe you an apology. I posted to try to get the trend of the thread away from politics and start a more photographic discussion about photo essays in general, but succeeded only in creating an opportunity for a latent expression of institutional bias and anger. I am sure it is disappointing for you.
Or are you merely mentioning 'these photos are from a past project, which I wished to post on this forum.' ?
OK, no problem.
It just struck me as a strange point. I can't imagine anyone asking Dorothea Lange for such a thing. Yet this photography became an icon of the Great Depression in America ... because we trust Dorothea.
Migrant Mother
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipe...tMother02.jpg/591px-Lange-MigrantMother02.jpg
Thank you very much for your behavior. It is really appreciated.
Funny! <the case of the missing thumb>I can never unsee the thumb.
king of the Migrant Mother, Laurent, I rather think she makes the case for the need for context. Here is an interesting essay about the photograph.
https://press.uchicago.edu/Misc/Chicago/316062
Now as then nobody knows who she really is or that she never was a pea picker.
Sorry about the link. Maybe <this one>? But obviously, you already know the story.Alas a pay wall.
I just want someone to sneaky sneak photoshop the thumb out cleanly.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?