Guys, if you do a search in the forum, you'll notice quite a few cases were Rodinal has gone bad within few years. AFAIK, in all of these cases the developer wasn't the late Agfa variant, or whoever produced that at any time, but the one produced by Calbe (and packed - sold under quite a lot different names - brands). Up to a point, you could determine what variant it is by the proposed dilutions. The Agfa variant had 1+25 and 1+50, while the Calbe one used 1+20 and 1+40 respectively. IIRC, Calbe's formulation has become a bit more concentrated and now matches the 1+25, 1+50 dilutions. This makes it harder to know what variant you have. For the record, my ~9 years old Rodinal (Agfa variant, produced by A&O) works fine, although quite dark.