The Mamiya RB67 user manual gives an example of DOF Scale use, with the 90mm at f/11 and focused at 15' , the DOF zone is said to be 10' to 30'.
In comparison, a DOF calculator programs says
- 'manufacturer standard' vision results in a DOF zone of 11-26'
- 20/20 vision results in actual DOF zone of 13'-17'
So that gives you an idea of just how good (not) the DOF Scale on the side is...it would take use of f/32 on the 20/20 vision DOF calculator (11' - 25') to match what Mamiya says happens at f/11 !
I tried to figure what circles of confusion (COC) your DOF app. surmises :
10' to 30' DOF for 15' focusing relates to COC = 0.08mm
11' to 26' DOF for 15' focusing relates to COC = 0.06mm
13' to 17' DOF for 15' focusing relates to COC = 0.02mm
The DOF given by Mamiya is a little laxist indeed.
The DOF tables for medium format (6x9 or 56x72) are usually computed for COC = 0.06mm
Of course, if you use very fine grain films, shoot on a tripod, want to enlarge much, you may choose a smaller COC, but 0.02mm seems to me more like the limit for 35mm shooting.
What seems clear to me is that distance scale on a plate on the camera body and only informative DOF scales on the lens, is not very comfortable (nor even suitable) for precise DOF control.
However, I use this (in my opinion) very simple method to compute mentally my own DOF tables "on the spot" :
First, I have computed and remember the hyperfocal of the given lens at a given diaphragm using this simple (however almost exact) formula :
h = f² / cD
h is the hyperfocal to remember, f is the focal length of the lens, D the diaphragm and c the COC that I want. Let's do it for the lens mentionned (f = 90mm) at D = 16 and with a rather small (for 56x72) COC of 0.05mm ; you find h = 10m (and have to remember just that).
Now, here are two simple (however almost exact for any focusing distances) formula that use only the focusing distance d and the remembered hyperfocal h to compute :
d' = hd / (h+d) the nearest acceptable distance for your chosen COC
d" = hd / (h-d) the farthest acceptable distance for your chosen COC
The interesting fact with this computation is that it uses only an addition or substraction, a multiplication and a division, which can be performed (almost) mentally and on figures in the same scale (all in meters !).
For instance, take d = 2m
d' = 10x2 / (10+2) = 20 / 12 = 1.67m (down to 33cm in front of the focused distance)
d" = 10x2 / (10-2) = 20 / 8 = 2.5m (up to 50cm behind the focused distance)
Easy ?
However, you had to remember the hyperfocal h = 10m only for D = 16 !
Because (look at the first formula) you see that D is under the fraction bar. so when you open the diaphragm (smaller Fstops) h will be proportionnaly larger and vice versa. So knowing only h=10m for D=16, you easily deduce :
h=14m for D=11
h=20m for D=8
h=28m for D=5.6
etc. and :
h=7m for D=22
h=5m for D=32
and so on.
I say I do this mentally, because DOF control needs not to be utterly precise, but using these simple computations instead of the "informative" scales on the Mamiya lenses, gives you the opportunity to choose your own COC ! And apart the "one to-be remembered hyperfocale h", the focusing distance d is the only parameter that you need to figure (roughly - either reading it on the distance scale plate or by pure estimate).
Bye, Paul