Proper exposure compensation for extension tubes

timllowe

I've seen several formula for calculating the exposure compensation required when using an extension tube. The one I use (and that makes sense to me) is

compensation = (focal length of lens + length of ext. tube)² / (focal length of lens)²

But I've seen a few other very plausible calculations yielding different results. As I only own a 21mm extension, the differences between the different methods doesn't make much of a difference. (I only shoot at the nearest half stop!) But I'd like to know out of curiosity and in case I get a longer tube or a wider lens. (I have only used the tube with an 80mm Planar and a 50mm Distagon.)

If anyone can site an authoritative source, I'd be forever grateful. Well... momentarily grateful anyway...
 

pentaxpete

Factor by which you multiply exposure can be found : (M+1) 2 where 'M' is the Magnification if known or can be calculated -- how do you get that 'small ' 2 for 'squared' on your computer !
 
OP
OP

timllowe

At least on a PC, there is an application called "Charmap" that you can use to put special characters (like "²") on the clipboard.

Can you expand your answer? What are the units of measure? An example like an 80mm lens with 20mm extension? Can you sit a source?

Thanks in advance!
 

pentaxpete

Not good at Maths but here goes : say your object is 2 inches long and you take it close-up so that it measures 2 inches on the focus screen then the 'Magnification' is 'same-size' or '1' so ( 1+1 ) 2 == 4 so you give 4 times the exposure say two shutter speeds LOWER or open up aperture by two stops.

Using YOUR measures I would use the OTHER Formula -- difficult to TYPE on this Computer but it is : Focal Length Squared divided by Extension Squared : so 80x80 divided by 20x20 = 16 which is the factor by which you multiply the exposure in your sample.
 
Cookies are required to use this site. You must accept them to continue using the site. Learn more…