OzJohn
Member
- Joined
- Feb 15, 2011
- Messages
- 302
- Format
- 35mm
There was an interesting discussion going on today at APUG that developed into a comparison between high ISO film and digital. Shame and scandal, but a couple of members declared that digital does a better job than film at high ISO - an opinion that anyone who has used pushed film and one of the newer, low noise DSLRs would share in a heartbeat.
APUG being what it is, this sort of discussion was headed for the dustbin real quick and sure enough a moderator jumped in and shut down the thread. This mod also moderates here too so obviously has, I would like to think, an interest in the broad spectrum of photography.
Here is the link to the closed thread:
(there was a url link here which no longer exists)
I suspect that more people than I would like to participate in some rational discussion regarding the strengths and weaknesses of both film and digital photography without the bile that issues from certain APUG posters at the mere mention of digital. Many photographers, myself included, practice both genres and while there are other open photo forums on the net, DPUG could surely use more members and more posts and maybe moderators could encourage more APUGers to have dual membership or more particularly shift their thread which is off topic to DPUG. I think that would gain more respect than a curt statement that the thread is off topic and shutting it down. OzJohn
APUG being what it is, this sort of discussion was headed for the dustbin real quick and sure enough a moderator jumped in and shut down the thread. This mod also moderates here too so obviously has, I would like to think, an interest in the broad spectrum of photography.
Here is the link to the closed thread:
(there was a url link here which no longer exists)
I suspect that more people than I would like to participate in some rational discussion regarding the strengths and weaknesses of both film and digital photography without the bile that issues from certain APUG posters at the mere mention of digital. Many photographers, myself included, practice both genres and while there are other open photo forums on the net, DPUG could surely use more members and more posts and maybe moderators could encourage more APUGers to have dual membership or more particularly shift their thread which is off topic to DPUG. I think that would gain more respect than a curt statement that the thread is off topic and shutting it down. OzJohn