• Welcome to Photrio!
    Registration is fast and free. Join today to unlock search, see fewer ads, and access all forum features.
    Click here to sign up

Paper developer: eco-friendly, odorless, fast, cheap, great tones?

The Chicken

A
The Chicken

  • 1
  • 3
  • 44
Amour - Paris

A
Amour - Paris

  • 1
  • 0
  • 63

Recent Classifieds

Forum statistics

Threads
203,236
Messages
2,851,884
Members
101,741
Latest member
Bruceluvsfilm
Recent bookmarks
0

cmo

Member
Allowing Ads
Joined
Aug 22, 2006
Messages
1,321
Format
35mm RF
Today I am starting to build a new, tiny darkroom. My first task are about 500 contact sheets from 35mm films, then I will get an enlarger and start to make prints again.

Of course, I cannot have my cake and eat it too - eco-friendly, odorless, fast, cheap, great tones, that sounds like a problem. But it's worth asking. Years ago I used Multigrade developer a lot, but it caused headaches, and I really hated the aroma.

BTW, I did not choose a paper yet. For the contact sheets 'cheap' is just right.

What can you recommend? Are there any recipes for a homebrew?
 
Almost all developers are 'eco friendly'. Developing agents hark back to tree bark extracts. Bromide and Carbonate come from the sea and the weeds therein. Sulfur is mined, but I find I need to add it to the vegetable patch, hardly a poison.

If it makes you feel better it is possible to make a developer from Vitamin C, and without sulfite:
http://www.unblinkingeye.com/Articles/VitC/vitc.html

You can buy developers that tout themselves as 'green' from digitaltruth.com and Freestyle. If they don't cost a lot less then they probably aren't in the Gainer vein.
 
I've been using Ethol LPD, as for economy in terms of dollars and waste I'd say it's a great bet. Stuff seems to last absolutely forever. All I've ever done is replace what the paper carries out and keep all the working solution.

Used my Jobo to print about 30 prints last weekend, started with 120ml and the paper carried out about 10-15ml for every 2 sheets.
 
Are you sure it was the MG Developer, and not the stop bath or fixer (perhaps with inadequate ventilation) that were causing your headaches?

I use MG and PQ ,and only notice a smell if I am close to the tray...and even then, it is a good smell; very "Earthy." Stop bath and fixer are far more pungent to me.
 
Those were my thoughts exactly. I doubt that the developer is causing you grief. I even doubt that the stop bath and fixer are causing you grief. If you're working in a small space without adequate ventilation, it is most likely that it's just getting stuffy in there. You're using up the oxygen and giving off CO2. A dose of fresh air will fix that in a hurry.

If you do find the smell of acetic acid stop bath objectionable (I' don't. Smells like vinegar to me.), substitute a citric acid stop bath for the acetic acid. If it's the fixer, try using a non-hardening rapid fixer. These have less acid and less odor. But mostly, get some ventilation in there, even if it means cracking the door open for a few minutes every quarter hour or so.
 
There are four common, and several more not-so-common, developing agents in B&W developers, especially print developers: metol (M), hydroquinone (Q), phenidone (P) and sodium ascorbate (C). (There are several variants on these, such as Dimezone S rather than phenidone or ascorbic acid rather than sodium ascorbate. These minor variants don't matter from health and environmental perspectives, AFAIK.) Many developers combine M or P with Q or C, as in an MQ developer, a PQ developer, or a PC developer. (MC developers exist, but are rare.) Less common developing agents include para-aminophenol, catechin, and various others.

From an environmental perspective, my limited understanding is that hydroquinone is arguably the worst of those I've mentioned, although I don't recall the details of why. (Possibly something about depleting oxygen in waterways?) The quantities you're likely to dispose of in a small home darkroom are tiny, though. From a health perspective, my limited understanding is that metol is the worst because some people develop rashes after repeated or prolonged exposure. OTOH, I've also seen claims that this is due to contaminants that were common in the past but that are less common today. If you want to do the absolute best thing from an environmental and health perspective, that then leaves you with PC formulations. My understanding is that phenidone is pretty benign, and of course ascorbic acid is also known as vitamin C, which of course we all need to survive.

Few commercial PC developers exist. For film, Kodak XTOL is the most common of these. Fomadon Excel is supposedly an XTOL clone, and Patterson has or had a PC developer, too, but I don't recall the name and I don't know if it's still available. For paper, Silvergrain Tektol and Agfa Neutol Plus (but not others in the Neutol line) are the only ones I know of, but I don't know if Neutol Plus is still being made.

There are several mix-it-yourself formulas. Nicholas has provided a link to some of Patrick Gainer's early efforts along these lines. His later PC-TEA and PC-Glycol have become fairly popular film developers, and XTOL clones like Mytol (same link) are also fairly popular. You could also check out Ryuji Suzuki's Dead Link Removed and paper developers. FWIW, DS-14 is the predecessor to Silvergrain Tektol. I use DS-14 myself. I use it with the replenisher, topping up my working bottle after each session, and it lasts forever that way, so it's pretty economical.

I can't comment on how any of these compare to (Ilford?) Multigrade's odor, since I've never used it. As others have suggested, you might consider stop bath, fixer, or general darkroom ventillation if you're getting headaches.

Of course, there are other ingredients other than the developing agents in any developer. Any of these could theoretically be bad for health and/or the environment. They tend to get less attention than other ingredients, though.
 
You can use the Chris Patton's Dektol as it can be found in the Darkroom Cookbook Second Edition. I don[t have the recipe in front of me, but it is made with Ascorbic acid and Phenidon as developing agents. It is very health-friendly, but I haven't try it and can't vouch for its photographic properties. If you want I can find the recipe, but you can do a search on Chris Patton's and Patrick Gainer's formulas for Vit C developers, try them and choose.

A.
 
You can use the Chris Patton's Dektol as it can be found in the Darkroom Cookbook Second Edition. I don[t have the recipe in front of me, but it is made with Ascorbic acid and Phenidon as developing agents.

I forgot about that one. It's called E-76, and the recipe is available online here, among other places.
 
Are you sure it was the MG Developer, and not the stop bath or fixer (perhaps with inadequate ventilation) that were causing your headaches?

I use MG and PQ ,and only notice a smell if I am close to the tray...and even then, it is a good smell; very "Earthy." Stop bath and fixer are far more pungent to me.

I used citric acid for the stop bath and an odorless fixer.
 
You may be allergic to some of the developer ingredients if you get headaches. Look at the ingredients in the ones that gave you problems and compare to the ones that are eco-friendly. You may find one that you will not be sensitive to.
 
I just tried the Moersch ECO 4812 positive developer. Not really fast with 3 minutes development time but has great results on PE or Baryt paper. And it's fully eco-friendly. As the manufacturer says 'It's supposed to be the best developer in the world'. From my short experience in darkroom work i would say that he is right.
 
Photrio.com contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
To read our full affiliate disclosure statement please click Here.

PHOTRIO PARTNERS EQUALLY FUNDING OUR COMMUNITY:



Ilford ADOX Freestyle Photographic Stearman Press Weldon Color Lab Blue Moon Camera & Machine
Top Bottom