As has been said before, masking tape comes in a number of forms and qualities. In general, it is neither strong nor very adhesive. There are no doubt exceptions, depending on brand and type. The film manufacturers use a very special plastic tape with a very aggressive adhesive. You can probably find something equivalent at the local store. I have used electrical tape for years without a problem. It is strong, but the adhesive is fairly weak - you have to be careful to attach it properly to the reel and the film. Gaffer tape sounds like a good idea - fairly thin, strong, good adhesive. In any case, be sure the tape is well attached to the film base.