Mythbusters: OJ film developer???

[srs5694]

I just watched tonight's episode of "Mythbusters" (on the Discovery Channel on US cable/satellite systems). For those not in the know, this show is devoted to testing urban legends, myths, etc., "scientifically." (Their scientific rigor seems to be about on a high school science fair level.)

Anyhow, tonight's episode was a "MacGyver Special," in which they tested some feats shown on the TV show "MacGyver." In one task, the hosts had to solve a number of MacGyver-style problems, one of which was developing a roll of film using their choice of a dozen or so common kitchen liquids. The hosts failed at this particular task, but viewers were told that the "correct" solution (presumably taken from the MacGyver TV show) was to develop in orange juice and fix in ammonium. This seems extremely wrong to me, but I thought I'd toss it out for opinions. The OJ would be at a very wrong acidity to develop film, would it not? Would there be any chance for it to work even if you added enough sodium carbonate or some other base? As for fixing, would plain household ammonium do anything at all? I thought it was the thiosulfate part of ammonium thiosulfate that was more critical in fixing film.

 

[JBrunner]

They should have picked coffee.....

 

[gainer]

OJ alone, no way. OJ + Tylenol + pH Plus or household ammonia stands a good chance.

 

[titrisol]

OJ has vitamin C, I would guess that adding Soda (carbonate) so that pH is alkaline it may work.
But as gadget said it is quite imporbable

 

[jim appleyard]

They'd have been better off using Kryptonite!

 

[Akki14]

homemade developer - instant coffee & washing soda (sodium carbonate)
homemade fix - allegedly the "make water safe for fish" drops contains sodium thiosulphate so in a pinch you could use that MAYBE but it's way more costly than fix so few people have tried it. I know a 250ml bottle of Tetra Aquasafe costs about £8 and there's lots of other stuff in it so it's probably not at the right concentration either.
Edit: actually Tetra Aquasafe is one brand that DOESN'T contain Sodium thiosulphate apparently (when I googled)

 

[Christopher Colley]

i wonder how many people made a mess AND ruined some film lastnight/today/whenever the reruns happen

 

[Toffle]

I'm more more inclined to use alternative chems for paper developing than film. I guess I'm just too afraid of ruining the raw material for printing. Also, the results on the print are readily apparent and can be applied to virtually any good negative. I have had some pretty good (if inconsistent) success with printing using Caffenol. In the case of Caffenol, the effect is more like that of toning developers.

If you're interested, here is an article I produced following my experiments with printing in Caffenol:
http://tomoverton.images.googlepages.com/caffenol

Cheers,

 

[Photo Engineer]

Orange juice contains vitamin C, ascorbic acid. They had bicarbonate of soda as well on the shelf. Those mixed until the foaming stopped and then addition of more bicarb would have made an alkaline solution of ascorbic acid. That might have developed film in about 1/2 hour or so. The ammonia would have fixed the film at least to the extent of rendering the image stable for a short time and viewable.

PE

 

[pauliej]

If the Mythbusters show was only about 10 or 15 minutes, without all the repetition and cerebral-ness (duh factor) it would be watchable and sometimes entertaining. As is they take all the fun out of it and take forever to get to the last 2 minutes where they finally shoot something or blow it up or whatever. What was the last show, showing how long it takes for grass to grow or paint to dry? BORING!!!

paulie

 

[srs5694]

I'd forgotten about the vitamin C in orange juice. Maybe I'll give it a try, just for the heck of it! Oh, and I do know about caffeinol, paRodinal, and other home-brew developers. I didn't mean to start a re-hash of discussions about them, just solicit opinions on OJ, since I didn't recall ever seeing it mentioned as a possible developer. FWIW, I didn't notice coffee amongst the products they had available, but they didn't provide viewers with a clear list, either.

 

[arigram]

A film developer using a imprisoned black boxer?
Now, that's seems a bit hard to make.

 

[rwyoung]

A film developer using a imprisoned black boxer?
Now, that's seems a bit hard to make.

Perhaps he has Alkaptonuria...

http://www.cmaj.ca/cgi/content/full/172/8/1002

 

[gainer]

He was a football player, and a very good one running back.

 

[knoxissimpler]

I tried this yesterday, it did develop the film when some soda was added, but the tank came open while agitating, and the lights were on so I sorta scrambled to get the developer to stop... was in for around 15 or 16 minutes.. the images that were visible were not really transparent (I assumed this was from not enough development time)... and I had to get out of there cause my time had run short (school hours)

but for my first time to actually develop the film myself (and since he still wont let me use his film developer) I rather enjoyed trying orange juice!

ADDITION: BTW, i used B&W film, T-Max 400

 

[john_s]

They would have been better trying human urine (I guess you might be able to call it a common bathroom liquid, if not a kitchen one).

 

[knoxissimpler]

tried coffee, didn't work

I tried the afore mentioned coffee, couldn't get it to work... and I still haven't had time to replicate the original results with OJ (need to find out what kind it was, I just found it at school)... any suggestions for when using coffee? I found that OJ tends to make a froth that keeps coming back...

 

[Akki14]

Coffee developer is slow and is a pull & staining developer. You'll lose about 1 stop of speed so overexpose your film by 1 stop. It takes about 30 minutes to develop. You are using washing soda not baking soda to change the pH, yes?
here's the recipes for caffenol
http://www.digitaltruth.com/techdata/caffenol.php

 

[knoxissimpler]

yes I am using washing soda, and thank you for telling me that I need some more exposure (really had no idea)... and good news, even though my OJ developed film never really became transparent enough, I still made a contact sheet and a enlarged print!... I'll try to post them tonight maybe..

 

[fhovie]

doesn't it have to be something someone has heard of to be a myth --- OJ as developer is not one I have heard.

 

[walter23]

(Their scientific rigor seems to be about on a high school science fair level.)

Yeah, you hit that nail on the head. I find their antics amusing, and sometimes they rig up pretty cool devices, but as "edutainment" goes it's heavily weighted on the "tainment" side of things. I always find myself cursing that they didn't bother to explain a physical principle even superficially, or that they never bother doing replicate experiments because of statistical variability, etc. But hey - it's all about blowing stuff up in amusing ways, and keeping the unwashed masses from changing the channel

 

[walter23]

If the Mythbusters show was only about 10 or 15 minutes, without all the repetition and cerebral-ness (duh factor) it would be watchable and sometimes entertaining. As is they take all the fun out of it and take forever to get to the last 2 minutes where they finally shoot something or blow it up or whatever. What was the last show, showing how long it takes for grass to grow or paint to dry? BORING!!!

The few times I watch it, I usually download .avi versions, and the fact that it's geared towards a station with constant commercial interruptions is apparent... the pattern is so annoying: 2 minutes of flashback, 2 minutes of new content, 2 minutes of "what's up next" <spot for commercial segment>, 2 minute flashback, 2 minute new content, 2 minute "up next", <spot for commercial>, etc.

I couldn't imagine having to put up with all that repetition plus a bunch of crappy commercials.

TV becomes so absurd once you've been away from it for a significant amount of time.

 

[rwyoung]

doesn't it have to be something someone has heard of to be a myth --- OJ as developer is not one I have heard.

Yes, but are you somebody? Just kidding, too easy to pass that one up.

I hadn't heard of the OJ version but until I tried Folgerol and Vit-C for myself a few years ago the did sound quite far-fetched. Not exactly mythic because there are several "reliable" references to them on the web.

 

[rwyoung]

TV becomes so absurd once you've been away from it for a significant amount of time.

Amen. I wish the production staffers had walked with the writers...

 

[Photo Engineer]

If you spend an hour reading APUG posts, and then spend an hour watching TV, the TV does not seem all that bad.

PE