- Joined
- Apr 15, 2010
- Messages
- 19
- Format
- Med. Format RF
Excluding any philosopical views on the tired digital vs film debate, has anyone on the APUG forum tested these two cameras next to each other purely to test the above criteria.
Well you asked if anyone on APUG had done the comparison. Just my left handed way of pointing out that this DPUG.Are you trying to get me into trouble Don? Ha! I HAD previously posted it in APUG and nearly got my head bitten off!
I think most of the differences pretty much boil down to the lenses you are using. Really good lenses in combination with a good drum scan can yield some incredible results.
When I agreed that he must find a high resolution DSLR more convienient for his type of work, he agreed but also added that the resolution he got with the D3x was equal or better than MF film taken with a Pentax 645N and produced better detail and tonal graduation as well.
Drop it in a mailer
Please, give us a break with this film vs. digital palaver.
Don
I was recently talking to a photographer who does child portraiture for a living. He has recently changed over from meduim format film to a Nikon D3x. When I agreed that he must find a high resolution DSLR more convienient for his type of work, he agreed but also added that the resolution he got with the D3x was equal or better than MF film taken with a Pentax 645N and produced better detail and tonal graduation as well.
Excluding any philosopical views on the tired digital vs film debate, has anyone on the APUG forum tested these two cameras next to each other purely to test the above criteria.
I'm a beginner but I would still be interested to know. Thanks, Sean
Also, if the guy is getting better detail and resolution from the D3X despite this, it is not surprising. IMHO, it takes an extremely skilled, careful, and diligent person to get the very best out of film. There are so many areas where great technical skill and near perfection are required to get the best out of film, and, frankly, those who are at this level are few and far between, so most people will truly get "better" results on digital once you factor this in.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?